ROK Drop

By GI Korea on July 6th, 2007 at 7:43 am

USFK Teens Convicted, Comparing Justice in Korea

The two USFK teenagers involved in the stabbing of a Taegu taxi driver have been found guilty and sentenced:

Two American teens accused of stabbing a Waegwon taxi driver celebrated Independence Day by walking out of a Daegu courtroom free Wednesday.

Marcus Banks, 18, who was convicted of the March 20 stabbing of taxi driver Park Sang-hui during a dispute over an unpaid taxi fare, was sentenced to two years and six months in prison, but the sentence was suspended for three years. His 16-year-old accomplice was sentenced on the same charges to one year and nine months in prison, but his sentence was suspended for two years.

Judge Yoon Jong-gu said he based his decision on the seriousness of the crime, the defendants’ ages and penalties for similar crimes in South Korea. The fact that both teens’ families paid the victim financial settlements — a common practice in South Korea — also played a factor, Yoon said.

I am actually surprised by this decision and the victim was as well:

Park blasted the judge’s decision outside the courtroom after the case. “I was dumbfounded, confused and unable to believe my ears. I expected [the younger defendant’s] sentence to be suspended, but how can Banks walk away?”

What I find surprising about the sentence is the fact that this crime was more serious than what happened the night of the "Great Shinchon Massacre". In the Taegu case the 18 year old stabbed the cab driver after he had committed a crime.

In the Shinchon stabbing incident the soldier pulled out a knife to defend himself only after he was descended upon by a Korean mob beating him to a pulp and the ironic thing is that this soldier was probably the only person involved in this incident that wasn’t drinking.  This soldier was initially charged with a lesser offense much like what the 18 year old in the Taegu incident was.  

However, the anti-US hate groups got involved, which ironically many of them were members of the mob that beat down the soldiers to begin with, and they demanded he be tried for attempted murder.  Due to the demands of the anti-US groups the judge raised the charges to attempted murder and the soldier was ultimately sentenced to two and half years in Korean prison.  The soldier was literally sacrificed at the altar of Korean public opinion.  To add insult to injury, no one in the Korean mob were ever tried for assaulting the soldiers; in fact they were treated as heroes.   

The incident involving the two USFK teens did not receive the same level of Korean media attention as the Shinchon incident thus the Korean judge could impose what he felt was a fair punishment and not what the anti-US hate groups thought was a fair punishment.  This is Korean justice at work, just ask PFC Acosta

You can read more over at Lost Nomad.

Print This Post Print This Post - 145 views
ROK Drop Forums
7
  • usinkorea
    9:49 am on July 6th, 2007 1

    The photos were one part the other was the fact the Shinchon guy was a full fledged GI.

    I ended up changing my vote to the idea the Shinchon stabbing was staged. Whatever the case, it is at least a 50/50 proposition the photos plastered everywhere from Shinchon is what gave the society the fuel it needed to become righteous and lead to the stiffer charge.

    Reply

  • Richardson
    11:02 am on July 6th, 2007 2

    The 18 year old is indeed lucky. In late 2002-2003 he’d be singing a different tune. I don’t know exactly how that tune goes, but guess it’s the one that means, “I’m the new beyotch on the cell block.”

    Reply

  • kingkitty
    5:34 pm on July 6th, 2007 3

    So the gave the name of the Mother (A SSG) but not the full name of the father (a Major)….and why is this

    Anyway I see nothing about these kids being sent back to the states…I guess its ok for them to be out past curfew while underage drinking and running away from their debts…..I dont care who the parts are….its time for these kids to go

    Reply

  • Dr.Yu
    11:37 pm on July 6th, 2007 4

    I´m glad for the kids. They got a sencond chance.
    Now what bothers me is the idea that maybe the judge might have been “pressured” to rule in favor of the kids. There are no evidence for such suspicion, but ….

    Reply

  • ChickenHaed
    12:58 am on July 7th, 2007 5

    You know…

    …it seems every dependent I have ever seen that had graduated from high school but was sticking around in Korea as a dependent was up to NO good.

    It this just my anecdotal impression or do others see it, too?

    J!

    Reply

  • GI Korea
    8:27 am on July 7th, 2007 6

    Chickenhead,

    I think you are on to something.

    Dr. Yu,

    What “pressure”? You obviously do not follow the Korean court system very closely. This is typical lax punishment from Korean courts. The only pressure that comes in GI cases is when the anti-US hate groups get involved.

    Reply

  • Dr.Yu
    12:19 pm on July 7th, 2007 7

    GI.
    Ok. Thanks for your explanation.

    Reply

 

RSS feed for comments on this post | TrackBack URI

By submitting a comment here you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution.

  • Translate

  • Featured Links

    LiNK Phrawgs Tavern Learn Korean with KoreanClass101.com

Recommended Reading

Bad Behavior has blocked 5178 access attempts in the last 7 days.