Could you imagine if such an order was put on Korean spouses married to USFK servicemembers?:
“My biggest concern is my wife,” said a civilian DOD worker who lives on Camp Lester. He asked to be referred to by just his first name, David.
“Her rights as a Japanese citizen are being infringed,” he said. “She’s not allowed to go to work or visit her family without special permission from the U.S. military? My children can’t visit their grandparents?
“We got an exemption for her work, but why did we have to do that?” David asked. “This ‘period of reflection’ doesn’t appear to have been thought out well. I mean, we even have to get permission to walk our dogs.” [Stars & Stripes]
Make sure to read the whole article, but the Marines are definitely taking this restriction very seriously. Supposedly dependents caught violating the order face being sent back to America for the offense. I don’t see how legally the Marine Corps command can restrict the movement of Japanese citizens or punish them if caught violating the order?
The people I’m sure are really feeling the pain of this restriction are the O-6 colonels that have to sign a document every time someone needs to walk their dog because they are the approval authority for every excemption to the order. I cannot imagine asking a brigade commander for permission to walk a dog, but that is where this restriction has led to.
One USFJ servicemember however seems to be thinking the same way I was earlier this week:
“I think that the restriction imposed on all DOD and family members was a great idea,” wrote a Marine gunnery sergeant. “The Okinawan community doesn’t realize how important the military is to its businesses and community. I parked in American Village before only to receive a flyer stating go back to America and thanks for Rock and Roll and cheeseburgers. I felt that was disrespectful. I hope the restriction will last till at least April or May so the Okinawans will be protesting about raising the restrictions so they can live.”
I would be amazed if this restriction continues into April or May because USFJ personnel all have their families with them and to keep wives and kids imprisoned in their homes for that long would be devestating for morale and would probably lead to a lot of angry letters and phone calls to members of Congress.
Here is what Air Force Command Chief Master Sgt. Craig Deatherage, the top enlisted servicemember for U.S. Forces Japan had to say about the "Period of Reflection":
“We are a reflection of society. There will always be that one or two people who do something that we find extremely disappointing. Their misconduct will highlight us in negative ways. I don’t think we can fix human nature.
“I think a relentless focus on our programs and our people and the focus on professionalism and their duties and responsibilities helps us to mitigate a lot of that. Statistically, in the last 20 years, we’ve seen an incredible improvement. But to eliminate every bit of it would be an unrealistic expectation.
“Certainly, we’re embarrassed every time one of our people’s misconduct highlights us. I guarantee you there are a lot of senior enlisted people out there right now, very focused on the conduct and behavior and what their people’s plans are for the weekend and talking to them about duty and responsibility and the fact that they are the face of our service to the Japanese people.” [Stars & Stripes]
Chief Master Sergeant have you been reading the ROK Drop by chance?
I have been saying this for years in regards to USFK crimes and recently in regards to USFJ crime that it is impossible to eliminate all crime in such a large population group. What you do is take all measures reasonably possible to limit crime and ensure it stays below the norms of the general population. However, what I do have to wonder is if USFJ is making this case strongly enough to the Japanese public that they are in fact being good citizens or is the Japanese public so invested in the image of the out of control Marines that there is nothing they can do to change it?







10:58 pm on February 28th, 2008 1
I recall Gen. LaPorte doing something similar. It worked out well for him.
Reply
3:36 am on February 29th, 2008 2
If you invited someone to your home who you didn’t know well and they raped your 14 year old daughter, what would you do?
Reply
7:26 am on February 29th, 2008 3
CrazyCorea, I would kill him on the spot. However the analogy is too simplistic. First of all the scumbag that is accused represents a dark side of human nature as alluded to by the Command Chief. We need to look at the larger set of numbers, as GI has done repeatedly, to put this in perspective. The Marines of the III MEF are probably the best-behaved division (plus) sized unit in the entire US military. I’ll bet the locals around Camp Pendleton or Camp Lejune, or even Bragg, Hood and Lewis deal with many more crimes that Okinawa or Korea.
People are people, and are prone to making stupid mistakes. To expect a large population of 18 to 24 year-old male to act perfect is unreasonable. Yes, our alleged criminal is 38. If guilty, he is a disgusting piece of crap and should be hung out to dry.
A better analogy would be if I was having a huge family reunion, and the neighbor boys, sons of my best friend, generally good kids, came over to the party. If one of them attempted to diddle with one of my daughters, I’d escort his sorry ass back to his parents in a public manner, and tell him to never come back. The remaining neighbor boys would learn something and can stay if they behave.
Reply
2:22 pm on February 29th, 2008 4
CrazyCorea, that is a good example of what happens with Koreans in the USA. They go to America and commit crimes. Kick them out.
Reply
9:30 pm on February 29th, 2008 5
As they so often do the Marines have taken this whole thing way too far. The point about Japanese citizens being denied their rights is important because it also transfers over to US dependents. USFJ is using the whole SOFA sponsorship issue to blackmail people into doing what they want-when what they want is against both Japanese and US law. It is wrong and you cannot legislate proper behavior anyway. You have to incentivize it.
What needs to happen is people put the screws on Congress and bring a lawsuit back in the US.
Reply
5:17 pm on March 1st, 2008 6
Skippy-san
The same thing happened in Korea and no one got any satisfaction when it was all said and done.
What happened with Local 1363 and the effort to get reimbursed?
Reply
7:24 pm on March 4th, 2008 7
[...] fact that Japanese citizens married to USFJ servicemembers was being restricted I found to be ridiculous and the restricting of civilian contractors was bound to become an issue as we have seen before in [...]
1:30 am on March 7th, 2008 8
[...] drunk and kill a Korean civilian and everyone could be locked down and having their own “Period of Reflection” in Korea even though the vast majority of servicemembers in Korea are not even allowed to [...]
11:40 pm on March 24th, 2008 9
[...] … http://www.kauaiworld.com/articles/2006/09/22/news/news02... [Found on Windows Live] 29. Okinawa ?Period of Reflection? Draws Criticism … concern is my wife,? said a civilian DOD worker who lives on Camp Lester. …. is people put [...]