Serving on the Forgotten Frontier

ROK Drop

July 31st, 2008 at 4:15 pm

Predictions for Future Protests (Part III)

Part III is our final Protest installment. It deals with our predictions of future protests. Large scale protests (1000-2000 people) will continue, but only for special occasions. Because the group’s support from the general public is dwindling, the protests with large numbers of protestors will be hard to sustain over a long period of time. Therefore, the activists will attempt to change to (1) Long-term protests; and (2) Guerilla hit-and-run protests. These protests are based upon the principle of ensuring maximum effectiveness (tying up the max numbers of riot police with max media coverage) with minimum amount of people committed at minimum risk. The tactics used during the 1990 protests will be reinvented.

Long term protests are nothing more than nuisance protests, but the solution is simple. Simply ignore these types of protests. The second type of guerilla hit-and-run protests can be divided into two types: (1) Small group hit-and-run operations (10-15 people); and (2) Large-group hit-and-run operations (100-200 people).

The small group operations are virtually impossible to stop. These protests will pop up with no prior warning and no fixed location. These protestors will be mostly gullible younger people — middle school and high school. The people will disrupt a road way or subway station — sometimes by violent means — and as soon as the police are dispatched, the group will disappear into the crowd or alleyways. The group will operate in small cells and receive clandestine instructions from activist NGO leadership — with the end result being that these groups cannot be attributed to any NGO. They will be faceless. There is NO solution to predict or prevent this type of protest.

The large scale hit-and-run protests (100-300 people) will operate differently. The activists have experimented with this type of protest on 20 Jul and 25-26 Jul to back up traffic in the Chongno area Rotary. Basically the protestors will play cat-and-mouse in a choke point (i.e., traffic circle) until traffic is backed up. Then like cockroaches when the light is turned on, they will scatter to their predetermined escape routes. The solution requires the police to be proactive and attack before the protestors are prepared. Though the protestor operations will change to take advantage of advances in technology, they are still the same ruthless tactics by hard-core activists.


PART III. PREDICTIONS IN PROTESTS

A. PREDICTION: LONG TERM PROTEST TECHNIQUE (1-10 PEOPLE) ATTEMPTS:

  • 1. PROBLEM: The long-term protests are based upon the principle of unpredictability in order to achieve its goals. The protestors state that the protest is “permanent” on a specific day of the week, but the group will NOT state the number of protestors that will show up. It could be one or it could be 100. The idea is that the police MUST plan for the maximum number and dispatch their troops accordingly. This is exactly what the progressive press needs for spectacular shots of one protestor facing off against 100 policemen. This method has been used successfully at the main gate of Kunsan AB for a number of years. We predict the activist NGO types of protests will try this method.
  •  

  • 2. SOLUTION: DO NOT PLAY THEIR GAME. DO NOT DISPATCH ANY RIOT POLICE TO COVER THESE PROTESTS. No riot police, no confrontation. No confrontation it is not newsworthy and the protest fails. END GAME. If the person attempts to sit in the middle of the street, simply arrest them for public endangerment. Then send the person to a state nuthouse for a psych evaluation as a hassle factor — claiming only an unbalanced person would block the streets with cars operating.
  •  

  • 3. BACKGROUND: KUNSAN AB: The principle of this type of operation is exemplified as to how the group in Kunsan AB has operated for years. Once a week, the protestors were to hold a protest in front of the gate. As a result the riot police were required to gather in force just in case and the USAF Security Forces were positioned at the main gate. The gate was locked down and all vehicular traffic had to be routed to the rear ROKAF gate. Without using a single person, the group was able to tie up one company of riot policemen and 10 or more Security Forces behind the locked gates.But the truth of the matter was that only one — but most times none at all — showed up. Then at other times, 15 would show up at the gate if there was a particular hot topic. It was very irregular, but most of the time it was NONE at the gate. This is the genius of this operation as the protestors did not even have to show up to tie up a company of riot police and a large group of Security Forces on the base. On many occasions, we have seen NO protestors there, but the riot police with their buses hidden in the side street and Security Forces dressed in their flak-vests sweating in the sun.Because the front gate was closed the entire base traffic had to be routed through the back gate. As a result there were long lines of people waiting to enter and leave the base. Onbase construction slowed down as trucks lined up. People attempting to get to work were delayed. The entire base operations slowed down.

 

  • 4. TACTICS: On 23 Jul, a small group of KBS union workers were still protesting the selection of the new KBS head. They were joined by other media activists that were protesting the new LMB media policies. But the main point is that these protestors were utilizing a small number of 10-15 people to tie up a company of riot policemen — while providing a photo op for the progressive media. The principle of minimum manpower with maximum effect — and minimal risk prevails.

    Again the solution for the riot police is to assess the violence risk. If the risk is near zero, DON’T SHOW UP because it is almost certain that the press is waiting to photograph the big bad police picking on the few protestors. The most likely venue the activists will select in Seoul is the Cheongye Stream — simply because the small size plus large pink shell structure are good backdrops for a small protest. In major cities, the location will be near the city center in a high visibility - high traffic area.As stated before, the best solution to this type of protest is simply to ignore it. If you take it seriously, it will last for years.

B. PREDICTION: SMALL GROUP OPERATIONS (10-15 PEOPLE) WILL INCREASE:

  • 1. PROBLEM: There will be small operations that aim to disrupt traffic or services and then the protestors will disappear rapidly. They will operate on the principle of maximum effectiveness (disruption of traffic/services) with minimum manpower (a small group of less than 100) — with minimal risk.
  •  

  • 2. SOLUTION: NONE. This is just about impossible to predict and stop. The protests cannot be predicted. The protestors are nearly impossible to catch as they scatter like cockroaches at the first sign of the police.The only positive note is that they do little damage and are primarily publicity seekers.

    The police will need to actively seek out the REAL organizers of these hit-and-run groups. As in the past, the organizers will most likely turn out to be the violent NGO activist groups. However, proving the NGO activist group connection will be very difficult unless an insider blows the whistle. The groups will funnel funds clandestinely to these small hit-and-run groups.

    Actually the funding will be very small — if at all. What the background organizers will provide is general direction for the group and suggest targets and prevent the duplication of protests from disparate groups at the same location. The local level cells will simply implement their own plans.

    As the operations are very simple and require no sophistication, the background organizers will have very little to do with the actual protest. As such they will leave no fingerprints to trace back to them.The unpredictable nature of these demonstrations upset people’s lives and when people get upset, they will strike out not against the protestors but against the government for failing to prevent these disruptions. People love regularity in their lives. It may sound stupid, but people do NOT like their routines to be upset. If their routines are upset, they will condemn not the protestors, but the government for failing to prevent them. That is why these types of protestors are dangerous as spreaders of anarchy and chaos.

  •  

  • 3. BACKGROUND: The idea of hit-and-run was perfected by the communist guerillas of Chiri Mountain before the Korean War in 1948 — and extended till 1954. The key to their strikes was unpredictability. The police never knew from what direction they would come, so everywhere had to be on alert. The operations were swift to move in and get out before the government forces could react. They always operated in small groups. If one member became separated, he was expendable. They were nearly impossible to catch. And above all they were ruthless — committing arson, theft, murder and summary executions.The 57th division and the 4th brigade led by Lee Hyun-sang fought their last battle at Daesung-gol about 50 years ago in 1954. The partisans, numbering only a few hundred, were attacked by a force of over 100,000 troops supported by heavy artillery and US war planes. The villages on Mt. Jiri were bombed and napalmed to the ground, and the inhabitants were summarily executed. Only a small number survived and surrendered — most were executed and a few were spared and spent decades in prison. Of the survivors, about 100 or so are still alive. Until recently, it was against law to sing ‘Communist’ songs or to mention the bloody guerrilla war that began in 1948 and went on until 1955 when the last guerrilla band was tracked down and killed off at Daesung-gol. (Source: Association for Asia Research and Korean War: Volume 1.)The modern day version of hit-and-run guerilla tactics were a result of the democratization movement and smaller NGO activist groups attempting to fight for their share of the public attention against a backdrop of violent workers strikes in the mid-1990s. Korean democratization began in 1988, but by the early 1990s had failed to bring tranquility to the streets or to replace protest with institutionalized political participation. Throughout Korea, the students took to the streets. However, in the mid-1990s, the job situation became critical and the democratizaton movement found it harder to find popular support in the colleges. It appeared that the violent street battles that it had waged in the early 1990s were coming to an end.At the same time, many grassroots activist NGOs were springing up. For example, the environmental movement in Korea was characterized by grassroots activists seeking to influence policy and challenge powerful polluting industries. In response to the environmental degradation caused by South Korea’s high-speed industrialization, small anti-pollution groups arose in the early 1980s. In the 1990s as more “green” groups emerged, Korean environmental activists created larger umbrella organizations to empower themselves. Soon Korean green civic groups undertook activities beyond the environmental sphere. Korean environmental groups became “department store” advocacy groups attempting to address a large number of issues both within and outside the environmental sphere. Many Korean environmental NGOs became active in the anti-war and peace movement. (Source: Green Activism and Civil Society in South Korea.) Some green groups joined other civic groups in the anti-war movement in inter-locking arrangements — thus such protests as the Maehangri Bombing Range.However, at the same time in the mid-1990s, large and violent workers conflicts broke out between the workers and the Kim Young-sam government. For example, in Dec 1996 the largest series of strikes and walkouts in South Korean history, involving hundreds of thousands of workers, took place to protest the new labor legislation that allows companies to lay off and fire workers more easily and to avoid paying overtime in a more flexible work system. In Jan 1997 150,000 workers, according to the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions, walked off their jobs to protest the new labor legislation. The wave of strikes had already “cost” South Korean corporations about $3 billion in lost production. (Source: Chronology of Asian and Oceanian Workers’ Struggles.)Against this background of workers protests, the attention for the various NGO activist groups and democratization protests was drawn away from their causes. To gain attention for their causes, the protests by NGO activist groups adopted guerilla hit-and-run methods. Small groups would stage “hit-and-run” protests to get publicity for their cause. The aim of the groups was to publicize their agendas that were not heard over the din of the large-scale protests of the worker strikes.These protests would mainly disrupt traffic and as swiftly as they appeared, the protestors would disappear. Many times these protests were so quick that the protestors would have to call in later to radio stations to confirm their groups action.Most of the hit-and-run guerilla demonstrations at the time were at train stations or streets leading to the train stations. It was thought the protestors were using the subways to escape.Later more bold demonstrations were held to block traffic, but mainly this was done on side streets — with the aim of backing up traffic and at the same time preventing the police from reaching them. These protestors disappeared into the side streets.These types of demonstrations were short-lived and the entire protest movement seemed to go into hybernation for a while after the “IMF Crisis” hit in 1997-1998.
  •  

  • 4. TACTICS: The main idea of guerilla style demonstrations is that they must do the maximum amount of damage with minimum numbers of manpower — with minimal risk of capture. It will be a swift demonstration lasting no more than an hour. To accomplish this task, the demonstrators must plan on swift disruptions to traffic that back things up. Then once that is done, it will take hours for the traffic to start moving smoothly again. They can announce their agenda at the protest with banners and ensure that the media is on hand to document their protest in photos — or they can announce their aim afterwards by phoning in to the media to take credit.The groups must maintain their unpredictability. These small group protestors — though working for different activist causes — cannot hit the same targets repeatedly. They need to rotate and mix up their protest locations to keep the police off balance. Thus this means there must be a central controller — probably from one of the main activist NGO “umbrella” groups — who will remain in the background and untraceable.Notification of progressive news media (i.e., KBS crews) for coverage will probably be done. The progressive media seem to have a close relationship with the progressive activists dating back to the 2002 anti-American hate fest. At that time, we noticed that the KBS new crews were always on-hand whenever there was a “spontaneous” protest or if there is a “spontaneous” anti-American incident. Throughout the past anti-US beef protests, the progressive media in their well-marked vehicles have been at every protest throughout the country mingling freely with the protestors — while conservative press representatives had to disguise themselves to mix with the crowds.
  •  

  • 5. TARGETS: Targets will be choke points to create the maximum amount of confusion/disruption. Escape routes need to be planned beforehand. If during the day, the best escape routes are through crowded shopping areas where it will be easy to blend in with the crowd. If the operation is at night, there should be dark alleyways to disappear into if the primary escape route becomes blocked. If possible, getaway cars should be parked on streets that will not be affected by the choke point.The operational plans for these guerilla operations need to be simple and of short duration. The targets will be choke points to do maximum damage by backing up traffic. What they want is the police to be dispatched to the area to investigate the traffic jam, but disappear before the police arrive there. Judging from past performance, it usually takes the police about an hour to appear because of the time lag from telephone complaints to assigning personnel to investigate. As a traffic incident, police do not react with great speed.If there is a minor fender-bender during the protest all the better. A small blockage of a choke point on a major artery will back up traffic rapidly — perhaps extending to the rear for miles. Then the protestors will disappear as swiftly as they started leaving the mess to sort itself out. The key is to disappear before the police have time to react and dispatch people to the scene.Again the goal is maximum effectiveness (disruption to traffic or services) with minimum personnel (10-15 people) — with minimal risk (swift escape from capture).
  •  

  • 6. DEMOGRAPHICS: YOUNGER GENERATION: We believe that the demographics of the hit-and-run guerillas will change to include even younger kids in middle school and high school. Police explained that while most of the instigators of violent anti-US beef protests were young men in their 20s and 30s with a few middle-aged ones in 40s and 50s, arrested people are mainly those who are dissatisfied with society like the homeless. The middle-aged activists are usually associated with organized groups (i.e., KCTU) while the homeless (living on the steps of Seoul Station) joined the violence simply as opportunities to vent their anger at society in general. These middle-aged and homeless do not fit well into the framework of a guerilla hit-and-run operation.Thus we believe the small group will be made up of those in the 20s or younger who are NOT linked with an organization, but formed through the internet to protest a specific cause. They will be those who meet on bulletin boards (i.e. Agora) and will be asked to join a specific protest as “volunteers”.These operations will be anonymous to prevent prosecution of the organizers. We believe that the group will be made up of small cluster groups that join together — most likely from bulletin boards that solicit “volunteers” via the internet and then cement the group through cellphone contact. Attempting to track these “phantom” groups will be very difficult as they will operate from PC bangs rather than homes or offices.There should be no lack of volunteers for these groups as they possess a mystique of being masked freedom fighters. Most of those attracted will be middle school and high school kids that are easily impressionable. During the 26-27 Jul protest, four of the 42 arrested were minors.A WORD OF CAUTION: We believe these types of guerillas pose a safety risk to the general public. These are NOT normal protestors, but anarchists spreading chaos and disorder. The ultimate goal of these people is to destabilize the government. If people feel “unsafe” in their daily lives, they will turn against the law-and-order elements for not doing their jobs. Yes, many will be youngsters duped by organizers, but this does not excuse them from being what they have become.The one principle that these new hit-and-run guerillas will learn is ruthlessness. In other words, they must not care if the small shop owner loses money in his business. They must not care if the auto with the punctured tire caused by his nails slams into a telephone pole. They must not even care if innocent bystanders are hurt in traffic accidents. Their purpose is to disrupt transportation and services to make a point — for whatever agenda they are supporting. They will have to truly believe that the ends justify the means.For this reason, the police need to treat these guerillas differently from the large scale protestors. These people are dangerous. Regardless whether they are very young or not, they need to be punished to the maximum extent of the law.There will be many younger people who will be duped into joining these groups under the mystique of “fighting for democracy” or fashioning themselves after past “student freedom fighters.” During the anti-US beef campaigns, many volunteers were duped by misinformation and outright lies to gain their support in the protests. The Korean youth are highly impressionable and can be used easily as shown by the violent demonstrations.These are misguided dupes will do all the legwork and dirty hands work with the protest, while the real culprits — activist NGO organizers — remain safely hidden in the background. Unfortunately, if these youngsters are caught in the act, they must be punished as though they are criminals because of the danger they pose to society.

    CURRENTLY THE POLICE ARE RELEASING THE MIDDLE SCHOOL AND HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS IMMEDIATELY. WE RECOMMEND THAT THIS STOP AT ONCE. Currently students are getting off scott-free because of their age. We recommend that these students be released to the custody of their parents — or principals of their schools if in the local area. Punishment will be meted out later — out of the sight of the police.

C. PREDICTION LARGE GROUP HIT-AND-RUN DEMONSTRATIONS (100-300 PEOPLE) WILL INCREASE:

  • 1. PROBLEM: There will be larger group operations aim to disrupt traffic or services. These groups will target traffic circles near major open markets in major cities to cause traffic jams. With their larger numbers, the group will also confront the police. As part of the protest, small groups will attempt to isolate members of the police and inflict violence upon them. When the police appear to be ready to strike back, the protestors will scatter in all directions on cue. The protestors are nearly impossible to catch as they scatter like cockroaches at the first sign of the police.They will operate on the principle of maximum effectiveness (disruption of traffic/services) with minimum manpower (a small group of less than 100) — with minimal risk.
  •  

  • 2. SOLUTION: PROACTIVE ACTION. Action must be swift before the protestors are allowed to inflict any damage. Unlike small group actions, these larger groups will be more predictable in the selection of their targets. They will select traffic circles with major open markets or red-light districts nearby. The markets or red-light districts are their escape routes. As such, police can plan in advance how to block the escape routes. However, the problem comes with unpredictability in when they will strike.Therefore, the police must be proactive and (1) Anticipate the actions of the group; (2) Strike immediately.By striking immediately we mean a two-prong approach with simultaneous action to (a) contain the protestors and (b) block their escape routes. The method would be what we call the Modified Ghenghis Khan Circle of Death — where the protestors are surrounded then the circle tightened.For a large group, this will mean encircling the entire group in the traffic circle — at the same time blocking escape routes. For smaller groups of the main group, the riot police would advance in a line and quickly spread out the wings — at the same time a rear echelon is moving up from the rear to block any escape. When the wings touch, the rear echelon will quickly move up to reinforce the wings.
  •  

  • 3. BACKGROUND: The basic idea of the hit-and-run tactic was from the communist guerillas of Chiri Mountain before the Korean War in 1948 — 1954. The key to their strikes was unpredictability and speed in completing an operation.This is actually a variation of the large scale protest with 1000-2000 people. However, the large scale demonstration is primarily against static defenses of bus barricades and police line. It also involved some well-publicized protest marches. On the other hand, the large group protest (100-200 people) are focused on causing a disruption at a major traffic circle or choke points in arteries leading to selected targets only.These protests are based on the principle of creating maximum disruption to services or traffic with minimal manpower — and minimal risk of capture.
  • 4. TACTICS: Unlike past anti-US beef protests, these will be of short duration, but high intensity. In other words, these people do not have the manpower to attack the static defenses (bus barricades), so they will create as much disruption in as short a time as possible. The large scale group (100-200 people) is a variation of the large scale protests with 1000-2000 people. The difference is the large scale protests normally attacked fixed static defense positions (bus barricades) and any police lines set up to block their advances. Protest marches were more for show and normally peaceful.On the other hand, the large group will only attack a police line in the initial stages — not with any hope of breaking the line, but more as a taunting mechanism to display a violent outburst in front of the waiting progressive camera crews alerted by the protestors prior to their arrival. Their operation is to evade the police. There will be no protest marches along a set route associated with their operations.The goal of the large group is to play a cat-and-mouse game with the police to exacerbate the traffic jam they have created in a traffic circle. The longer they keep the protest going, the further the cars will be backed up. A short 20-minute demonstration may back up cars that takes two hours to unsnarl. An example of this type of guerilla hit-and-run was seen on 20 Jul at the Chongno traffic circle when the protestors would simply run away from the police and start in another direction.On cue, these groups will scatter like cockroaches with each person heading for the escape route he/she has preselected. Like the protests in the 1980s-1990s that used this technique, the majority of the protestors will usually escape. The key will be to be able to break and run BEFORE the police start their actions to block off the exits and encircle them.
  • 5. TARGETS: The primary targets will be traffic circles and choke points leading to the major targets. For example, instead of protesting in front of Yongsan’s Main Gate, the protestors will attempt to block the main arteries leading to the Main Gate. These protests will be unpredictable and occur without warning. Thus people normally using the Main Gate will be caught in a traffic jam lasting hours. There can be many variations of this with the main purpose being to disrupt the traffic and services — allow the traffic to back up and disperse if possible before the police arrive.The targets will be planned carefully to find areas which have escape routes for the protestors. If traffic circles, the protestors will look for locations with an open market or red-light district nearby. If the target is a choke point, the protestors will look for residential areas; or in older areas, where the shops have many twisting backalleys.

6. DEMOGRAPHICS: HARD-CORE ACTIVISTS WITH INTER-LOCKING AGREEMENTS: For larger demonstrations there will have to be an organization. The current inter-locking agreements between activist NGO groups, a small group of 10-15 could call up other groups to supply manpower for a short demonstration to lock up traffic and then disappear. The promise from the small group is that next time their group would join the other group’s protest. In this way, different activist groups with disparate agendas could support each other with manpower.Contact could be through cellphones and anonymity of the group protected if they operate outside the leadership of the group. The object is to provide the leaders of the various NGO groups with deniability (i.e., “I didn’t know beforehand about the protest.”).The use of interlocking groups was formulated in the late 1990s under the idea of a umbrella cover group — normally with an inflated title such as “Pan-Korea XXX” or “Unified Council of XXX”. For example, in the mid-1990s, Green Korea United joined with the anti-war groups to battle the US possession of Maehangri. During the past anti-US beef protests these interlocking agreements were used by environmentalists, unification groups, anti-war groups and activist religious groups to form a committee to organize the protests.However, now that the government is going after the organizers of the groups, the new guerilla tactics will be anonymous. The signs of the demonstrators may show the cause, but they will not show the identity of the group or homepage URLs on the banners as seen in past protests.A recent example of this interlocking agreements was when over 100 KCTU officials and some 300 civic activists staged a sit-in overnight on 25 Jul at the KCTU headquarters as some 600 police officers surrounded the area in an attempt to arrest its three leaders. This protest was peaceful, though the leaders are fugitives holed up in the Jogye Order temple.Though they may believe they are fighting for a just cause, they are simply hooligans with no regard to the safety of the general public. These people have consciously chosen to endanger the lives of the general public — with the goal to disrupt society as anarchists. The majority of the people involved with large scale protests are hard-core activists from the Hanchongryeon and NGO activist groups — with assistance from leftist unions such as the KCTU or KEWTU.

D. PREDICTION: FUTURE TARGETS = “CHOKE POINTS”: Primarily they will seek to block the roads at choke points to disrupt traffic and/or cause a traffic jam.

The most important part is they need photographic evidence of their protest for publicity. The progressive media (i.e., KBS) has in the past always been notified of the locations in advance and could be trusted not to notify the police. If not, photos taken by the protestors themselves and then published on the internet will suffice.

The intent is to create a disturbance that is large enough to be news-worthy in order to get the publicity. For example, drivers in the downtown area of Seoul were caught in the middle as protesters suddenly appeared on the roads, and the police could do nothing but watch. Demonstrators began their all-out guerilla strategy from 1 a.m. 20 Jul, simply changing direction when police blocked their way. This lasted for seven hours in the pouring rain. About 400 cars were caught for more than 30 minutes between the Seodaemun Station and Dongnimmun. (Source: Chosun Ilbo

The police in the 20 Jul protests showed the changes from static demonstrations (attacks on bus barricades) to the new hit-and-run tactics. The police could not cope and stood by helplessly. The police need to develop tactics and strategics to block the escape routes BEFORE attempting to confront the protestors. They need to be PROACTIVE in attacking the protestors without notice and encircling them before they can react.

  • 1. Roads: The accustomed gathering places and venues for past protests will no longer be selected. In selecting a road to block there will be two considerations. (1). Is it a major artery where traffic can be backed up? (2). Is there an escape route easily accessible from the street stoppage area?In the past, large open areas were chosen for large scale protests, such as Seoul Plaza or Yongsan Main Gate, but these areas provide no means of escape. With the diminished amounts of people involved, the guerilla tactics will probably concentrate on immobilizing choke points instead.Choke points provide maximum effectiveness with minimal manpower. For example, if one wanted to protest at Camp Humphreys, the attack would not be at the main gate of Camp Humphreys, but at the Pyeongtaek off-ramp leading to Anjung-ni. In addition, the attack should also block traffic leading from Anjung-ni right where it turns into Pyeongtaek. Once the traffic is backed up, it will take hours to untangle — and the protestors will be long gone by then. The protestors would disappear to awaiting cars on the side roads that are not blocked.For military camps, the roads leading to the older camps are usually very narrow and easy to block. Most of these roads are two lane traffic until they near the main gate areas where once blocked in, a car usually doesn’t have room to backup and leave the area. Once the traffic is backed up, the protestors can disappear leaving a traffic mess to clear up for the police who will be struggling to get to the scene.
  • 2. Traffic circles (Rotaries) Ideal chokepoints are traffic circles in major cities. A stoppage will back up traffic in four or more directions. As these are normal chokepoints, the traffic will be traveling at low speeds minimizing the risk to the protestors. Once traffic is stopped, a traffic snarl will develop in minutes. Once traffic is backed up, the group will disperse before the police arrive.The traffic circles that will be selected are those with a large open market or red-light district nearby. These will be the planned escape routes for the protestors.
  • 3. Subway/Railway Stations: If disrupting services such as the railway transportation flow of traffic, there is always a danger of being trapped within the station itself. Therefore, the disruption should be in areas feeding the railway station rather than at the railway station itself. As most railway stations also have a redlight district nearby, it is an ideal location to use as escape routes. During the daylight hours, an area near a outdoor shopping area or open market are ideal escape routes — especially if filled with innocent bystanders.On 23 Jul, college students gathered at Seoul Station to protest. The pattern will be of disrupting a large amount of people attempting to head home with minimal amounts of protestors — and if the riot police show up, the disruption then becomes even greater. With 200-300 people, you can create a major disruption in the transportation system by blocking people’s entrance/exit to and from the subway. Probably the most popular method will be the sitdown strike to block the stairs leading up and down to the platforms at a subway station. There will be a lot of angry people but most will not attack the protestors and simply look for another exit. They will notify the police, but by the time the police arrive, they will have dispersed. This is simply and inconvenience method — but still effective. The protestors will have the advantage of being able to meld into the crowds and depart the area using the subway.
  • 4 Public bus transportation: This could be as simple as creating a blockage of the intra-city bus lane of a major city where at a large number of intra-city bus lines intersect — or better yet blocking the entire street. For example, at major subway stations the bus lines intersect. There are usually bus stops where many intracity bus lines stop. Buses on a tight schedule will simply bypass any blockage leaving people stranded — causing a disruption of service. These blockages would have to be done by large group (1,000-3,000 demonstrations as it is shutting down a major artery.For intercity bus traffic, the roads leading to the bus terminal are best. Unfortunately, most of these locations have police stations nearby making them poor choices. These blockages would have to be done by large group (1,000-3,000 people) demonstrations.
  • 5. Air transportation: The same goes for choke points leading to the major airports. Most regional airports usually have only one developed road leading to and from the airports. The blockage of the roads will stop cargo and passengers from reaching their flights. However, because only a few people are usually affected, these are probably not good choices for protests. Remember that the rule is for a maximum disruption of service in order to gain publicity. These will probably be left alone.
  • 6. Ship terminals/Cargo container terminals: Most passenger ship terminals are located in the outer port areas of the harbor cities. There are usually multiple choke points. However, because this will impact only a few people, it probably will not be undertaken. Remember that the rule is for a maximum disruption of service in order to gain publicity. These will probably be left alone.Stoppages of a cargo terminal will probably NOT be effective because there are too many entrances and exits for the container trucks. The KCTU has practiced this form of blockage in the past during the anti-US beef demonstrations at the warehouses in Yongin. As a hit-and-run tactic it will not be effective.
  • 7. Public Services: These are usually out of the scope of hit-and-run protestors because of the technical problems. If they attempt to disrupt electrical or water systems, these pose grave danger for the perpetrator of the act — as well as to bystanders who may get electrocuted or have similar harm done to them. As most of the hit-and-run guerillas will be young, most will not have the expertise to accomplish this. In addition, these types of sabotage are usually for very refined activist groups or communist infiltrators. We believe that there will be no attempts to disrupt the public services by these hit-and-run groups.
  • 8. Internet Hacking/Server Attacks: This is the greatest danger area from these guerilla groups. Many are computer literate and attempts will be made to hack into government systems simply to disrupt services.The favorite technique of the younger internet users is to simply overload a server by making too many inquiries in a short space of time. These can be easily coordinated through the internet. Though this would not be generally listed under hit-and-run crimes, the impacts are as great or greater than those of the physical hit-and-run protestors. In recent months, this technique has been used against the KNP and Chosun/Joongang/Donga newspapers to shut down their servers.But the major problem is that the protestors have now progressed to the level of being thugs. After the shops in the Chonggak area moved to sue the organizers for recompensation, the internet group published their names and phone numbers on the internet. Immediately the shops were besieged by threatening phone calls and people blocking the entrance to the shops. Threatening phone calls have also been received at government agencies.By publishing the names, phone numbers and addresses of the individuals that offend the activist NGO group organizers, the accused people will be subject to intimidation and threats.

E. PREDICTION: COORDINATION VIA INTERNET AND CELLPHONES:

As was shown by the latest anti-US beef protests, the power of the internet cannot be underestimated. Intercommunication through text messaging has also been shown to be very effective. To set up a demonstration, a bulletin board (i.e., Agora on Daum) can start looking for “volunteers.” They will be told to visit a chat site where they will be recruited. Once set up, the people would become part of a “cell” of 10-15 and the organizers will encourage new members to recruit their friends. Each of the cells will be autonomous to ensure that if there is a breach in security, only a small number of people will be affected.

Targets will be selected by shadowy NGO activist groups working in the background. The information will be passed to the “cell” leader. After a target is selected and escape routes planned, the entire group would be told where to assemble using mass text messaging. The group will be briefed and implement the plan.

First attempts will probably be very clumsy and unsuccessful. However, the groups will learn from their mistakes and become more proficient at disruptions after a few times. Like the activist NGO groups between 2002-2003, there first results to obtain attention for their causes were very poor. However, once they joined forces, they started to gain the public attention and achieved their goals.

It is possible that the police could infiltrate a group, but there will be too many autonomous groups floating around. The police could attempt to monitor and trace the IPs of individuals, but the chances are slim for its success as the police cannot monitor ALL the bulletin boards and chat rooms 24 hours a day.

If you’re thinking that this all sounds much like the US Communist Party operations of the early 1950s, you are right. But then look at the activist NGO groups and key players. The activist NGO groups represented during the latest anti-US beef protests along with the KEWTU and KCTU all are demanding the right to visit North Korea in August — to coordinate with their peers in friendship.

F. PREDICTION: WEAPONS BECOME TOOLS:

According to police, metal pipes that symbolize violent protests appeared four times between June and July during which candlelight vigils were held on and off. The metal pipes were used on June 7, 26 and 28, and suddenly reappeared on July 17. It was revealed that they fully planned and prepared for the violent protest, shooting the police with slingshots and preparing raincoats in case police use the water canon. “These protesters prepared beforehand one metal pipe, two hammers and one fire shooter to stage a violent and radical rally,” explained police.

However, in the future, we believe that dangerous weapons such as pipes and poles will disappear simply because of the transportation problems and the inability to disguise these weapons on public transportation. The use of the long multi-battery flashlights that can be used as a club will probably NOT be chosen as it is a close-in, hand-to-hand combat weapon and is also too heavy to carry. The squirt guns filled with acid will also fall out of use. Sling shots with metal ball bearings may fall out of use. The new weapons/tools of the guerilla hit-and-run protestors will be lightweight, portable and disposable.

The aim for a guerilla operation will be weapons/tools to be used to immobilize traffic or a service operation– NOT for personal protection or for inflicting harm to the police. The objective will be to disappear BEFORE the police arrive, so even for large scale groups (100-200 people), the idea of getting into a face-to-face conflict in which they are outnumbered is discarded. The new weapons/tools will NOT be for face-to-face conflicts with police.

Therefore, the type of weapons will be light-weight and disposable — and dual purpose. We believe the new weapon of choice will be the spray paint can. It can be used to leave grafitti messages on buildings and structures. At the same time, it makes an excellent flamethrower — in conjunction with a hand-held lighter — for short distance to back up any hostile crowds.

Flags and banners will still be an integral part of any protest as the items are very portable. The pole consists of the collapsable fishing rod and a nylon flag/banner can be easily folded to fit into a backpack. As a weapon, the fiberglass fishing rods were seen in the past protests being used against the riot police as the protestors beat upon them with the poles.

We also believe that protestors will start carrying some tools such as hammers and pliers/bolt cutters to break into buildings or cut off locks on gates to make their getaway. These tools may assist the hit-and-run guerillas as they will be improvising on most of their attacks. The hammers will prove useful if hammering nails to make a picket to flatten tires — or deface public buildings. The hammer can also be used to attack car windshields to create confusion and chaos in affecting their escape.

Nails and brads can be used to disable tires but these probably will be of limited value. The spreading of nails and brads onto a street will only cause slow leaks to tires. Those with simply welding skills may fabricate these brads beforehand in home workshops. An X-board with nails embedded thrown across a street will cause instant blowouts — and hopefully accidents to tie up a road for hours. Again we repeat the protestors must be ruthless and not care if others sustain injuries.

We noticed in the 19 Jul demonstration, the protestors used roman candles to fire over the heads of the police. This was only used as a taunting tool — hoping that the police would turn on the water cannons. In the hit-and-run tactics, these types of fireworks are worthless, but may find other uses in creating confusion and chaos to disrupt operations. Again the hit-and-run protestors intended to NOT get into a face-off with police operating under the principle of maximum effectiveness with minimum personnel and minimal risk.

Popularity: 3%

Tags: ,
- 775 views
47
  • King Baeksu
    8:18 pm on July 31st, 2008 1

    Kalani, good job again as usual.

    You seem well-versed in the demographics and sociology of these protesters, and the question I want to ask you is this: Why Korea? Why do there continue to be so many protests here in comparison to other countries? What is it about Korea or Korean culture that either exacerbates or perpetuates this culture of continual confrontation in the streets?

    I’m also curious what you know about the communist group “All Together” (Ta Hamkke). They seem to be at every one of these anti-USS2MB (Anti-US Sogogi and Anti-Lee Myung-bak) demos and their flag is always at the front of the barricades. In fact, I think I see their flag more often than even Agora’s. So obviously they must be onvolved in the organizing, no? How are they able to maintain such a high profile without any seeming consequences so far?

  • Kalani
    8:25 pm on August 1st, 2008 2

    Koreans have had protests in modern times from the independence movement in the 1900s to peasant uprisings to the present riots against Syngman Rhee, Park Chung-hee, Chun Doo-hwan, etal. To outsiders they seem to be a connected string of some sort of continuum — that implies that Koreans are genetically predisposed to violent behavior. But as one looks at each protest or riot they all are different — and each had a different root. They also show that there is a growing and maturing process going on. The protests/riots were instruments of change to move the society to the next level of development. Even failed protests brought about changes in the society.

    Yes, there are some common threads. The foremost element in all seems to be nationalism. Love of nation has been embedded in the national psyche because of the Confuscian roots that has a hierarchy of order — where everything has its proper place with the king/father/eldest male at the top … along with the sense of oneness as indicated by the Korean use of “us”/family/nation that takes precedence over the “I”/individual.

    Another thread for recent protests is that Koreans have been weaned on the idea of students being in the forefront of all changes in Korea. They believe they are the ones who took to the streets to topple Syngman Rhee and all the other regimes. This common mystique attracts the young and idealistic who seem to be looking for the chance for THEIR TURN to shine. They are looking for something to protest — anything at all so they can go down in the history books as their generation’s “freedom fighters”.

    However, I will condemned for what I say next, but I believe the students may have come first, but it was only when their mothers and fathers hit the streets — the common man — that the regimes buckled. Chun Doo-hwan was not afraid of the students when he stepped aside for Roh Tae-woo as his designate to power. It was when the mothers and fathers and common man hit the streets.

    This was the same idea that the progressives tried to use in the latest anti-US beef protests. It started with the misguided kids as “freedom fighters” against 2MB and then it brought out the common folks — and then the hard-core activists took over. Too bad the common-man revolt peaked too soon and fizzled. Its only the hard-core activists now.

    As to the “communists” involvement question, I am highly opinionated on this matter. If I stated what I believed here I would be openly condemned for my biased views. I wrote a long foot-noted paper years ago where I pointed out how the communists had infiltrated the unions, academia and service industries. I documented the North Korean infiltrators caught in the steets, kidnappings of South Koreans, etc., etc. I showed the cases of long-term spies in academia (i.e., SNU)and cases of South Korean railway and water service workers who were actually shipped in from North Korea as middle-school kids and sent to South Korean schools living at infiltrator safe-houses with their “South Korean” families. There was a lot more — but the bottomline is that I now believe that the majority of South Koreans don’t really give a damn if they exist or not. They don’t care that their coastline is so porous to North Korean infiltrators that Kim Young-sam just gave up trying to protect the coastline.

    So what I’m saying is that a communist flag — or even a North Korean flag — in front of the protests doesn’t really phase me too much. It doesn’t panic me. I believe, if it doesn’t panic the South Koreans — and the NIS — and DSC — and the KNP, it certainly doesn’t concern me.

  • Kalani
    10:20 pm on August 1st, 2008 3

    Watch the practice session this weekend (2-3 Aug) to see if the protestors will go for daytime disruptions at traffic circles — and peaceful candlelight vigils at night pattern.

    It’s been soggy wet on the past weekends. This weekend prediction for thunderstorms Sat and clear on Sun., but its been pretty dry out. The activists may test out the new protest pattern this weekend.

    Both sides supposed to protest. With candlelight vigils at night, it will aid police as progressives are nocturnal by nature, while conservatives have been usually daylight protests. The police who won’t have to deploy extra forces to keep the two sides separated.

    Will be interesting if they employ the new Special Tactics unit whose leaders have had experience handling this type of hit-and-run protests in traffic circles back in the mid-1990s. Back then the police were much more “forceful” — a polite word for “brutal” — so I wonder if they have mellowed.

  • Kalani
    10:16 pm on August 2nd, 2008 4

    2115/2 Aug. I was wrong — raining in Seoul. Watching on Hankyoreh Live Internet how the “march” is stalled. The protestors have blocked the road and cars are forced to turn back. No candle vigil.

    I assume there is a police picket line up ahead and the Hanchongryeon coordinators don’t know what to do. The group is relatively small though a lot of banners. At this moment, they are lined up, but not moving.

  • Kalani
    10:31 pm on August 2nd, 2008 5

    2125/2 Aug. This is the “large group (100-300)” that I described above. The police are executing the trap of blocking the exit mentioned in this text. To the rear of the group in a police line — keeping their distance.

    I assume to the front is another picket line of police. They are trapped — and are planning a side movement to get out but there is no feasible route. It is too late to scatter. They are trapped. To me there is no alternative except to call it a night and go home — but they would lose face.

  • Kalani
    11:11 pm on August 2nd, 2008 6

    2135/2 Aug. Police order to disperse. Rear echelon moves up — takes the sidewalks. People ordered to clear the streets and move to sidewalks.

    2145/2 Aug. Police move up streets to clear out the hard-core never-say-die protestors. A few whack jobs wanted to fight and for a while police were running here and there.

    2200/2 Aug. Street open and traffic flow normal.

    2210/2 Aug. Protestors now on streets and start their chants again for Lee Myeong-bak to get out. YAWN…protest over. Short one from Ulchiro 2ga to Myeongdong.

  • King Baeksu
    1:59 am on August 3rd, 2008 7

    Comment removed at author’s request.

  • RWPEDO
    3:45 am on August 3rd, 2008 8

    DUBWA RETURND DOKDO TO KOREA!!! YOU SHOULD RESPECT HIM FOR RETURING DOKDO TO KOREA. JAPS ALMOST STOLE DOKDO, WHICH CAN NEVER BE ARGUED IS ANYTING OTHER THEN KOREAN FOR OVER 5000 YEARS. ARROGANT AMERIANS HAVE NO SUCH UDERSTANDIGN OF HISTORY. BECAUSE ARROGANT AMERICA IS ONLE NEW COUNTRY WITHOUT ANY HANRYU. ALL OVER ASIA KOREA IS WORSHIPPED AND TO STEAL DOKDO IS TO STEAL THE BEAUTY OF KOREA FROM ALL ASIA. ARROGANT AMERICAN CAN”T UNDERSTAND THAT!!! APOLOGIZE!!!

    YOU MUST APOLOGIZE!!!

  • Kalani
    4:18 am on August 3rd, 2008 9

    Scott,

    Nice writeup. Again would like permission to use it on my chronicles of the protests.

    Wow…they used hoses from a tanker truck??? Another of my suggestions. Don’t worry…I know that the KNP is not reading my garbage, but it just shows that devious minds think alike.

    As to turning on the hoses on the “reporters” I say, “Go ahead.” These “reporters” actually instigate trouble by their presence. During the Chinese Olympic Torch Relay incident, if you look closely at the videos, you’ll see the front rank of “attackers” are actually press folks vying to get the best shot. It was a media circus and a contrived hoopla that almost caused an international incident. They are doing the same here during the past anti-US beef protests. I say spray them and they will learn how to be a combat photographer — you don’t stick your head up when you are in the line of fire. You hang back behind cover.

    Also if a lot of the phoney “reporters” get sprayed, so be it. When they yank them out of the line because they are dyed, let them try to explain how they are reporters to the police with bogus credentials. Yep…join the boys and girls going to jail.

  • Kalani
    4:26 am on August 3rd, 2008 10

    RWPEDO — Wow…if you’re right, then Tangun and the Bear lady knew about Dokdo 5,000 years ago. Great historical fact for the World Courts (ICJ)!!!

    But really…are you an American troll just messin’ with us? Regardless, this is the wrong thread.

  • King Baeksu
    4:36 am on August 3rd, 2008 11

    Kalani, feel free to use what you need of my write-up.

    I have seen these reporters throughout the protests but tonight they were definitely blocking the police much more than usual. It almost seemed like it was a conscious strategy.

    Wonder how big the turn-out will be on the 5th?

  • Brendan Brown
    11:29 pm on August 3rd, 2008 12

    And yet ‘real’ reporters (kind of a mismoner in Korea I know) such as those from the Chosun Ilbo get beaten up by these thugs.

  • Brendan Brown
    11:30 pm on August 3rd, 2008 13

    ‘misnomer’ sorry.

  • CINA
    11:52 pm on August 3rd, 2008 14

    Kramer auto Pingback[...] Predictions for Future Protests (Part III) Well, even it’s really hard stuff (f.. long articles) you MUST READ it, to “enjoy” it!! [...]

  • Kalani
    6:56 pm on August 4th, 2008 15

    Heo Jae-hyun, a Hankyoreh reporter, is arrested in Myeongdong in central Seoul on August 2.

    At the time of his arrest, Heo was in the process of reporting on a recent candlelight protest in which 10,000 people participated, as estimated by the People’s Countermeasure Council against Mad Cow Disease. The demonstration was largely organized as a protest against U.S. President George W. Bush’s upcoming visit to Korea. Heo and 13 other people were arrested.

    http://english.hani.co.kr/arti/english_edition/e_entertainment/302312.html

    Scott,

    Your description of the disturbance by the police was actually a Hankyoreh reporter. Another paper reported this “disturbance”, but didn’t mention he was a reporter. As I said before, these reporters are not above “creating” news if there is nothing to report.

    Also note how the Hankyoreh said there were 10,000 in the crowd. I wonder where they were all hiding? Also for a candlelight protest, where were all the candles?

    All the more reason for the police to spray everyone creating trouble — including the progressive press.

  • King Baeksu
    8:30 pm on August 4th, 2008 16

    Kalani, definitely there were no more than 2,000 people but I’d say closer to 1,000 or 1,500 by the time they got to Myong-dong. Also the headline is very misleading. A few people were chanting against Bush but not against the US, and in fact most people were chanting against 2MB and the police… I’m not sure if the Hani incident was by the police car or not, but he must have been doing something extremely egregious to get nabbed. I was near there as well and hundreds of riot police rushed right by me and didn’t even touch me. It was the equivalent of scuba diving and being in the middle of a giant school of fish. In fact, I nodded at a couple police to acknowledge them and the nodded back very politely…

  • In Seoul
    9:05 pm on August 4th, 2008 17

    King Baeksu, do you know the specific location of the protests tomorrow night?

  • King Baeksu
    9:36 pm on August 4th, 2008 18

    In Seoul, it’ll start at Ch’onggye Plaza at 7pm. I presume that the police will block off the back entrances of the Plaza, which will force the protesters to go down into the stream and then exit several blocks east in Ulchiro. I presume this is intentional on the part of the police because if they can hold the line at Ulchiro (and keep the protesters from heading up to Chongno), it forces the protesters to retreat south to Myong-dong, which is much farther away from Kwanghwamun and the main road to the Blue House — their desired target, of course. Not so great for shoppers in Myong-dong, but then again that may be intentional on the part of the police as well, since that will piss off the generally politically apathetic folks who tend to congregate in Myong-dong as well.

  • King Baeksu
    9:44 pm on August 4th, 2008 19

    On the other hand, the protesters may have seen what happened last Sat. night and have some sort of counterplan. However, they’ve already printed up all their stickers indicating Ch’onggye Plaza is the rallying point, and the police certainly aren’t going to let them ruin Seoul Plaza again. I guess everyone will have to play things by ear!

  • In Seoul
    9:45 pm on August 4th, 2008 20

    Thanks for the info, King Baeksu. :smile:

  • King Baeksu
    11:50 pm on August 4th, 2008 21

    No problem, In Seoul. And if they want to burn a few flags, those candles will come in extra handy, won’t they?

    I’ll probably keep a low profile, but if any bald eagles are in danger of being sacrificed, I may just have to exercise an intervention!

  • Kalani
    6:54 pm on August 5th, 2008 22

    6 pm/5 Aug: See from the progressive media that the Chonggye protests are underway waiting for the start at 7 pm. However, where are the Hanchongryeon students who were to be protesting at the US Embassy? The progressive media seems to have a news blackout on their whereabouts. Hope they don’t do something stupid like making an end-run towards Cheong Wa Dae — which would be the last thing they wrote.

    Truthfully, if these people are as intelligent as I hope they are, they will not do anything foolish and it’ll be a peaceful evening. Anyway, Scott, keep your head down and hang back. There are some whackos in that crowd.

  • King Baeksu
    7:36 pm on August 5th, 2008 23

    If anyone’s interested in an update, I had dinner and then at 5:30pm passed by City Hall and it was absoultely packed with pro-US demonstrators, at least 50,000 people. Half of the crowd was veterans’ groups in uniform and half ordinary people including a lot of younger people. Everyone was waving US and Korean flags together, and a woman on stage sang the US national anthem and then the Korean national anthem. There were big signs everywhere saying “Welcome President Bush,” “Freedom Isn’t Free” and “Stop the Illegal Candlelight Vigils.” Pretty insane that so many people were there, and you could barely walk it was so crowded.

    Then I passed by Ch’onggye Plaza and at 6pm there were about 30 or 40 students sitting on the ground wearing sashes that read “Bush, renegotiate at once!” There was a line of police in front of them and things seemed peaceful, but I noticed a college kid walk by carrying a giant water gun which is definitely bad news — those always come out on the more violent nights.

    At 5pm about 750 people were having some sort of anti-war demonstration at Boshingak and a lot of the same progressive banners that you see at the anti-beef demos were there, so they will either head to Ch’onggye Plaza near 7pm, or possibly the small group at Ch’onggye Plaza now is a decoy and the people at Chonggak will head in their own direction. There are police everywhere around Chonggak now, however, including a water cannon, so I don’t think they’ll get very far.

  • Kalani
    8:27 pm on August 5th, 2008 24

    7:30pm — The flags joined the group at the Pink Shell on the Chonggye Stream. Internet live on Hankyoreh had the conservative rally on split screen before, but now only the progressives. Boring… You can watch the live internet broadcast on the link below.

    http://www.hani.co.kr/section-popup/pop_0805.html

  • In Seoul
    10:29 pm on August 5th, 2008 25

    I am amazed that these protesters bring small children to these protests. As a parent, I would simply say that this is an example incredibly bad parenting. It seemed pretty clear to me that the police were being egged on to confrontation. In fact on my way back through Myung-dong, two policemen, who had done absolutely nothing wrong, where surrounded and being physical abused by a bunch of middle aged men. These people are really dragging this country down! I had to leave by 8:30, but it was probably just as well.

  • King Baeksu
    1:11 am on August 6th, 2008 26

    As I described last Sat. only more so, the press REALLY got in the way tonight snd REALLY interfered with the police doing their job. There must have been 200 “reporters” taking pictures every time the police tried to use the water hose, which then obviously made it nearly impossible to use. I mean, how many millions of pictures of riot police can you take? The point, of course, is that these reporters were essentially functioning as activists themelves and running interference for the other protesters, but get a pass because they have a “Citizen Reporter” badge on the side of their arm. They also swarmed on police every time the police arrested someone, also making it impossible for the police to do their job.

    The protesters were going crazy when I left at 10:30pm. Apparently the wingnuts were out in force tonight and running amok because of Bush, although they were still whining about renegotiating the beef deal every chance they could get. They were attacking regular people in Chongno-3-ga repeatedly. It was digusting, especially when a mob of 50 people were chasing a 60-year-old haraboji down the street and calling him a “New Rightist” (and “traitor” and “Jap”) just because he’d dared to disagree with them. Fortunately, he was able to get into a police box before he was really hurt, but I saw him get kicked and hit several times by people twenty years younger than him. The main culprit was from the “Anti Lee Myung-bak” cafe, and judgeing by the way he was boasting of his exploits afterwards to his mates, he was quite proud of the way he had beat up an old haraboji for “democracy’s sake.”

    I almost got into a sticky situation myself but fortunately no damage was done. I think the special unit guys are going to come out after midnight — I didn’t see any earlier — and really crack some heads.

    All I can say about this place is that it must suck being such a small and insignificant country. A small dog barks the loudest, as they say, and a small country like Korea apparently feels it has no other option in life but protest and whine all the time about every little thing.

    What a sad place.

  • Kalani
    5:33 am on August 6th, 2008 27

    Some Lessons Learned from last nights’ affair.

    At 8 pm, the progressive were starting their chants against “Bushee” and getting ready to do something, but we were not sure what. Everyone turned around to march, but the way was blocked by a police line at the other end. Before they could take to the streets, the riot police moved forward and blocked the way. Some fools tried to shove and were immediately arrested. A handicapped man in a wheelchair was pulled off to the side by the riot police — out of the way of the advancing police line — as he screamed at the police. The police were proactive as we had recommended — and the march was over before it even started.

    The riot police moved up the sides along the Chonggye stream and the protestors were pushed back and the riot police cleared the area. Frustrated, the protestors mingled along the edges of the Chonggye Stream trying to figure out what to do next. Facing the police line, it was a stalemate. At 8:15, they formed up again and tried to face-off the police on the far end of the Chonggye stream but the police weren’t budging. The police held the intersection and no one was going to pass. The protestors drifted off to confront the police line near the Pink Shell. This time a water cannon started up at 8:20 pm. The protestors backed off immediately.

    LESSON LEARNED 1: Being proactive works.

    At 9 pm the riot police with body armor showed up. These were not the young recruits, but seasoned veterans judging from their age. They started to form up and encircle the protestors with the banners. At 9:15 they moved in pushing the protestors down Chongno 1-ga. At 9:25 the police pulled back. The riot police reformed along the sidewalks.

    The press rushed to the front to photograph the protestors. Suddenly there were the glare of camera crew lights. Prominent now with the street open was the white and yellow water cannons that now had a clear run at the protestors. We were wondering what was going to happen next. The press was again mingling freely with the protestors at Chonggakyeok-Sageori.

    At 9:35 the water cannon turned around and left. This was a complete surprise. Then we saw why — in the center of the mess was Kang Ki-gap and the politicians. The police returned to a standoff position blocking the streets. Then they turned around and left. This was an even greater surprise. Kang Ki-gap used this break in the action to effect a mass escape from the trap. (He led the police on a merry chase through Chongno and Saegeori through Ulchiro and then through Chongmoo-ro to Myeongdong.

    LESSON LEARNED 2: Don’t give the bastards a break — even if there are politicians involved. You’ll end up paying for it in the shorts. The water cannons were pulled off when Kang Ki-gap’s groups was passing through Ulchiro using hit-and-run techniques to create havoc.

    LESSON LEARNED 3: Kang Ki-gap is using his political status to break the law. NO ONE IS ABOVE THE LAW. Get LMB to say so. They have done this over and over again in the anti-US beef protests and still are at it.

    At 10:40 the riot police moved forward at a run. More protestors were hauled away — but some protest sympathizers to the rear were trying to stop them. The other riot police had to come to their aid. Protestors on the sidewalk became a problem and had to be sealed off by the riot police.

    LESSON LEARNED 4: Don’t let the “curiousity seekers” get behind you. They may be protestors in disguise. When attacking treating, treat everyone as a “enemy”. Tell them to disperse immediately — and if not, cart them off to jail.

    As the police moved forward, so did the white and yellow water cannons. Then the protestors pulled out their roman candles and started shooting them at the riot police. At 10:05 as the roman candles were still shooting, the yellow water cannon let loose first followed by the white water cannon.

    LESSON LEARNED 5: Don’t give the bastards a break. They were using the roman candles again.

    LESSON LEARNED 6: The dye works on cotton fabrics, but ain’t worth a darn on polyesters.

    LESSON LEARNED 7: The hand-held spray nozzles work better than the truck mounted as you only want to mark the front ranks and then haul them off.

    At 11:15 between Chongno 2-ga-3-ga, protestors gathered on the sidewalk chanting anti-Bush and LMB slogans — as well as calling the police brutality in arresting the protestors. The riot police reinforcements showed up at 11:20 and immediately the people scattered to the four winds. It was the hit-and-run tactics that we had talked about before.

    At 12 pm there was an example of the hit-and-guerilla tactics on Chongno 2-ga where a group could be seen assembling to start to disrupt traffic when they take their protest to the street — and when the police show up they intended to scatter again. Another group was seen gathering to use the hit-and-run tactics near Chongno Station. Supposedly 200-300 people were to gather there according to the broadcaster.

    LESSON LEARNED 8: Small group Hit-and-run tactics work. It’s going to be a long summer.

    At the end of the Myeongdong Catholic Church face-off, the crowd isolated two policemen and were going to beat them if other riot police had not come to their rescue.

    LESSON LEARNED 9: These are hard-core activists. Even though the police showed mercy in letting the protestors go scott-free, didn’t mean the protestors wouldn’t stab them in the back. Put the word out — if they try the isolate the policeman trick again, the police will take them down WITH ALL MEANS AVAILABLE to rescue their own.

    Will anyone learn from this? Nah…

  • chefantwon
    7:07 am on August 6th, 2008 28

    Looks like you folks are have lots of fun over there. Stay safe and don’t get hurt.

    Man, those kids just love to protest. They have been at this stuff at least since 1990, when will they grow up and learn they are being used?

    Love the reporting.

  • Kalani
    11:38 am on August 6th, 2008 29

    LESSON LEARNED: THE WATER CANNON WITH DYE IS NOT EFFECTIVE!!!

    We observed the yellow water cannon appeared to be shooting dyed water. The white water cannon was not. Later we observed the riot police up on the truck turning on the valve for the portable nozzle to shoot a spray from the police line.

    LESSON LEARNED 1: Previously we said the color must be odious otherwise it will become a “badge of courage”. The orange color is like liquified jello color. The dye needs to be a permanent marker — NOT food coloring which is what I suspect they used. It is great on coton, but worthless on polyester. A photo of a woman protestor showed only small spots on her face — like she was splattered — and no real damage at all to her blouse.

    LESSON LEARNED 2: The protestors are NOT afraid of the water spray. It MUST contain a small amount of liquid tear gas agent to cause discomfort. The low pressure gun though effective is application, was not effective because of the water contained a worthless dye combination and no liquid tear gas component. The protestors will laugh at it.

    When they switched over to the dye, they reduced the use from high-pressure to low-pressure. We believe this is a good decision to prevent injuries to the protestors and resultant bad press, BUT without having some “fear-factor” involved, they simply destroyed its effectiveness.

    In the BBC video, the activist in his 40s with all the bravado of a true patriot ready to die for his cause stood with his hands on his hips defiantly taunting the riot police to spray him. The policeman sprayed him. However, besides wetting him down, there seemed to be no visible difference. It was totally ineffective.

    The police MUST add liquid tear gas immediately to the mix and MUST change the dye composition to a PERMANENT marker (i.e., bank liquid splatter dye-packs that “soaks” into money fibers). Color must be odious (i.e., bank liquid dye in purple and green).

    Again — will anyone listen to this? NAH….

  • King Baeksu
    12:13 pm on August 6th, 2008 30

    “In the BBC video, the activist in his 40s with all the bravado of a true patriot ready to die for his cause stood with his hands on his hips defiantly taunting the riot police to spray him. The policeman sprayed him. However, besides wetting him down, there seemed to be no visible difference. It was totally ineffective.”

    What the video doesn’t show is:

    1. When the police first rushed forward with the hose, they were doing fine until a mob of “reporters” swarmed in front of the police and literally blocked them. The police thus were immobilized for several minutes as they tried to figure out what to do, and in that time that’s when the man referred to above stepped up to the front. But if the “journalists” hadn’t delayed the police in the first place, that man wouldn’t have been able to do what he did at all.

    2. Why did the police try to use the water hose in the first place? Because the protesters were throwing eggs and bottles at the police, and some of the bottles were not plastic water bottles but glass soju bottles. I have pictures of this — shattered glass all over the street. The people throwing the bottles were young college kids and a few older types wearing bandanas around their face. They were also pulling away metal traffic guards onto the sidewalk and trying to form barricades to block the police from moving forward. All of this is very provocative behavior at a “peaceful” protest and yet the end is that that older man getting sprayed comes out looking like some sort of brave martyr. He was on the top page of OhMyNews, in fact.

    Ridiculous. Where are the pictures of the soju bottles being thrown at police? Where are the pictures of the pro-Bush ajumma who got beaten up by other protesters right before the spraying incident described at the top of this comment by Kalani (they even grabbed her sign and US flag and ripped them up before kicking her)? Where are the pictures of the haraboji getting kicked and hit by protesters in Chongno-3-ga? Where are the pictures of the drunken homeless guy getting attacked from behind by protesters? Where are the pictures of another ajossshi in Chongno-3-ga who was mobbed on by protesters?

    The “reporters” here have abdicated their responsibility by not covering all sides of this story. More to the point, they are interfering with the police doing their job. They are not “reporters” — they are propagandists pure and simple. They wear “kija” badges on their arms, but that is an insult to the noble profession of gathering the news. There should be some sort of official agency that looks into this group of people because they are absolutely shameless and utterly unprofessional.

  • King Baeksu
    12:44 pm on August 6th, 2008 31

    By the way, here is what a Korean friend of mine, who is very liberal, wrote about Hankyoreh’s coverage last night. Do they sound like “fair and balanced” reporters to you?:

    “And yesterday I was angry with Hankyoreh’s live report, they called this demonstration a candlelit culture festival.( ?? ???). But that was a totally a riot! And the reporter ridiculed the policemen and color cannon and policemen’s arresting of demonstrators.”

    At what kind of “culture festival” do harabojis and ajummas get kicked and hit and attacked?

  • Kalani
    12:48 pm on August 6th, 2008 32

    “…Police, however, promptly dispersed the crowd, firing water canons and sealing off the streets with vehicles. The water contained tear-causing chemicals and red color to track down targets.”

    http://english.yonhapnews.co.kr/national/2008/08/06/0302000000AEN20080806000900315.HTML

    We may have to retract what we said about there being no tear-gas agent in the mix. We now recall one leader at the Myeongdong Catholic Church face-off being fanned by another person we thought because he was overheated. But there may have been fumes coming from his clothes — but still there was no tearing effects noted.

    HOWEVER, we saw NO tearing effects as we have seen in the past when cayenne pepper from extinguishers or aerosol pepper sprays were used. We know first-hand how tear gas affects the body. We saw NONE of the effects in the protests after the water cannon was used on the internet broadcast of the protest.

    We saw no evidence of the “red color to track them down”. The group at the Myeongdong Church were in the front lines and all were unmarked as far as we could see on the broadcast. The photos in the progressive media do not show any color traces — and we did NOT observe in the progressive broadcasts any police arresting people because of their clothing coloration.

    Did anyone else observe something? Anyone see (or smell) anything?

  • King Baeksu
    1:04 pm on August 6th, 2008 33

    Kalani, they used yellow dye by Ch’onggye Plaza at around 8pm and I noticed yellow spots on some protesters’ clothes. Later on Chongno they used red dye in the water which was quite visible as it was being sprayed but I, too, was puzzled by the fact that no one’s clothes seemed to be stained. I assumed that they had simply ran away fast enough, or perhaps had brought a change of clothing. I cannot comment on the tear gas except to say that earlier at Ch’onggye Plaza it did not seem to be in use, and I certainly did not smell anything.

    Kalani, if you’re going to rely on Korean media to get your facts, you’ll just wind up driving yourself crazy in the end.

  • In Seoul
    1:08 pm on August 6th, 2008 34

    King Beaksu, have you heard anything about the protesters’ agenda for this evening?

  • Kalani
    1:21 pm on August 6th, 2008 35

    “Kalani, if you’re going to rely on Korean media to get your facts, you’ll just wind up driving yourself crazy in the end.”

    Scott,

    I hear you. The trouble is that is Yonhap News — which is considered the OFFICIAL news agency for Korea (i.e., the party line)…though sometimes I wonder. It’s where other media sources get their “facts.”

    Whoops, gotta split…got classes. Will check back on this thread when I get to my office to see what’s your opinion on what’s going to happen tonight.

  • In Seoul
    1:42 pm on August 6th, 2008 36

    My wife just came home on a bus. She said the news she heard on the radio stated there was a big group of protesters headed for the Yongsan garrison. She also said the police were already lining the streets. I guess President Bush must be visiting the troops. Has anyone heard anything about this one?

  • King Baeksu
    1:44 pm on August 6th, 2008 37

    In Seoul, Kalani, I don’t know what’s going to happen tonight but I think last night was the big night (won’t Bush already be gone by this evening anyway?). I think it is dangerous for foreigners to be at any events tonight, especially later on. What happened to me last night is that I took a picture of two protesters attacking the aforementioned drunk homeless guy and suddenly a mob tried to attack me. At first they screamed, “He took a picture!” which is a pretty ridiculous charge, so then another guy said, “He’s a police informant!” and then later he actually lied and clained that I had hit him in the face. Amazing. Fortunately, a Korean friend I know from an NGO was there and he blocked these lunatics and vouched for me, but they did manage to tear my shirt before I got away. Anyway, my friend advised me that with Bush in town, these people were totally out of control and getting “lynched” (his words) was a real possibility, so that’s why I called it an early night last night.

    This is the real face of these so-called “peaceful democrats” — attacking people for the “crime” of taking a picture!

  • Kalani
    2:01 pm on August 6th, 2008 38

    Your take is exactly like what I see.

    I saw caucasians — unknown nationality — defiantly standing their ground in the protests to either police or protestor. Stupid move.

    I saw many Caucasian faces in the Myeongdong face-off last night that got pounced on by the “press” for their authoritative opinions on the protests. However, it it had been an anti-Bush = anti-US mood, they could just as easily have turned on them.

    Years ago, we called it “situation awareness” in knowing what’s going on around you. The first rule is this is Korea and it belongs to the Koreans. Stay out of their way. Second rule, if trouble is brewing find a nice cool bar with a good view to enjoy the fireworks without being a participant.

    That’s why I enjoy the internet live broadcasts so much. It gives a bird’s eye view without having to get into the thick of things — though your views are being censored. So turn the sound off and just watch the pictures.

    I agree with you that last night was the hard-core activists one last shot — but I think tonight spells a new chapter. The anti-US beef protests are dead and the old anti-US agenda is now going to be the latest “new” topic.

    LMB is slowly strangling these activists — and he’s doing it legally which is what is torquing them off. To divert the attention, they need something fast and the old hate the American has always been convenient.

    We’ll see what happens tonight. I believe the activists want to keep the momentum they achieved last night going and switch to a new topic. They tried this in the anti-US beef protests and it fizzled. I think they’ll try to resurrect this again — otherwise why the anti-Iraq/Afghanistan deployment ploys.

  • In Seoul
    2:01 pm on August 6th, 2008 39

    Thanks for the input, King Baeksu.

  • King Baeksu
    2:33 pm on August 6th, 2008 40

    BTW, the protests were covered by ABC News last night:

    http://abcnews.go.com/Video/playerIndex?id=5520873

    It says “Webcast” so I’m not sure if it was broadcast on TV in the US or not.

    I met the reporter, David Kerley, last night. He was pretty full of himself. I introduced myself, said I’d lived in Chongno for 12 years and been going to the protests every night and was an expert on them and offered to explain anything he was curious about, and he replied smugly, “I think I’ve got it pretty well under control. It’s all about the beef, man.” I replied, “It WAS about the beef, but tonight is different. Tonight it’s anti-Bush and anti-US.”

    You can see from his report that he had decided to focus on the beef issue to the exlusion of most everything else, even though the beef issue seems to be over at this point. You can also see in the middle of the video the pro-Bush ajumma I mentioned who later got beaten up.

    That idiot organizer he interviewed at Chogye-sa is complaining that the beef deal was “humiliating” for Korea. Doesn’t the US have similiar beef deals with like half the countries of the world? If all these leftists and unionists think the beef deal is so humiliating for South Korea, maybe they don’t need to sell their cars or flat-screen TVs in the US any more? If they want to be blind nationalists, then they should walk the walk and not just talk the talk.

    And I also think the US should pull out of Korea because I am personally offended that my mother and father have to spend their tax money here supporting such hypocritical and shameless people. It’s time for them to defend their own country for a change.

  • King Baeksu
    2:52 pm on August 6th, 2008 41

    BTW, the woman at the end of the video says, “I think US beef is dangerous.”

    No, what’s dangerous is violent protesters attacking ordinary citizens on a systematic basis over the course of weeks.

    I’ll bet if I told that woman I was attacked last night, she would think I was making it up, because these noble protesters are defending the nation against “dangerous US beef.”

    Of course, these people are probably brainwashed Hankyoreh and OhMyNews readers, but I’m surprised that reporter didn’t try to deconstruct what they were saying a little bit more aggressively. I also told him that they were attacking regular citizens but he is clearly sypathetic to them in his report. Why didn’t he show that ajumma getting beaten up just minutes later? Perhaps he had already retired to the 18th Floor of the nearby Seoul Foreign Correspondents Club to sip a few beers and bask in the glory of being a glamorous foreign correspondent?

  • In Seoul
    2:57 pm on August 6th, 2008 42

    Frankly, King Baeksu, I think most of the U.S. media and the people as a whole are clueless about Korea. This may be why there seem to be so few negative economic and political consequences for Korea in spite of all the anti-Americanism over here. I think the Korean left finds it beneficial when the average American is ill informed or intentionally misled about the motives behind these protests .

  • King Baeksu
    8:59 pm on August 6th, 2008 43

    Quick update here: I passed by the US Embassy at 3:00pm and again at 7:45pm and it was pretty dead out in front — no “freedom fighters” anywhere.

    At 7:30pm, Ch’onggye Plaza was also nearly empty and there weren’t even any police to be seen in the vicinity. A construction crew was setting up a gigantic stage for the Olympics, sponsored by SK Telecom. I assume it must be some sort of outdoor viewing venue a la the World Cup games.

    It seems that the orgy of nationalism will finally shift its focus elsewhere for the next two weeks or so. Good news for the government, not such good news for folks such as myself who are quite disgusted by all the nationalism in this part of the world.

    Somehow, I don’t think the Koreans are going to get much of a welcome reception in Beijing either.

  • Brendan Brown
    10:26 pm on August 6th, 2008 44

    Scott.
    Once again much appreciated your on the ground first hand reports. Ironically all those phony ‘reporters’ don’t get a finger laid on them because of their ‘credentials’ while the only real writer (you) get physically harassed.
    And as your friend I implore you to take care. My Hangyeoreh reading student/friend was horrifed when I told him I went to a demonstration–and that was June 25 when things such as attacking innocent bystanders wasn’t out of control like it is now. These racist dead-enders who aren’t even bothering to put up much of an image anymore would love to kick the shit out of a white guy (and an American to boot.) Last Friday morning while the rest of the country was still on ‘Tokdo fever’ Rev Han and Hanchonryun were out in force outside the US embassy. Although I’m sure they hate Japan, that hatred is somewhat masked due to Japan’s ‘Asianess’.

  • King Baeksu
    10:54 pm on August 6th, 2008 45

    Hey Brendan, thanks for the support. I think I’m done with these protests. They already have huge posters up in Chongno advertising for a big rally on the 15th, Liberation Day. Their agenda according to the poster includes — along with anti-mad-cow disease — anti-FTA, anti-Iraq War, anti-Afghanistan involvement and anti-cost-sharing related to US troops here. I’m sure cattle ranchers in Texas will be happy to know that not only is their beef poisonous, but it’s also being linked to the war in Iraq. Why don’t these people throw in global warming and a few more random issues and call it a baker’s dozen?

    The fact that no one turned up tonight and that now these people are talking about the Iraq war and Afghanistan means that contrary to what David Kerley of ABC News thinks, “It’s NOT all about the beef, man.”

    It’s been fun y’all, but I think this will be my last post for now. Enjoy the rest of the summer!

  • New Elements in Old Protest Culture
    1:30 am on August 7th, 2008 46

    [...] started to leave this as a comment on one of Kalani’s posts when I decided it might be better done as a post of its own.  It meanders - so sorry about [...]

  • Kalani
    1:53 am on August 7th, 2008 47

    Scott — take a well-earned break. Appreciate your first-hand reports on all the goings on. But now it’s time to just kick back and enjoy the summer. Thanks again for the reports.

 

RSS feed for comments on this post | TrackBack URI

By submitting a comment here you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution.