You just gotta love that after all these years of Amnesty International paying little more than lip service to the massive system of concentration camps in North Korea while at the same time promoting non-stop Gitmo campaigns is now coming out and trying to make it seem like they actually care about human rights in North Korea. Here is the guy T. Kumar who has been all over the media claiming to be a North Korea human rights expert:
In this CNN interview he claims that Amnesty International has been conducting investigations of North Korean human rights abuses for the past two years. I find that interesting because if you look on the Amnesty International website in their North Korea section in the two year period of 2007-2008 there was not one report about the human rights of North Korean defectors. In fact the only article they had was in 2007 about two North Korean soldiers being executed by the regime. For supposedly launching some investigation into the human rights of North Korean defectors for the past two years Amnesty International couldn’t produce one report to put on the North Korean section of their website. The other reports they got on there are reports where North Korea is lumped in with other countries that have the death penalty for instance.
Now take a look at their South Korean section. It is filled with reports every month condemning the South Korean government yet for North Korea we are lucky to see one North Korea specific report a year. I am not even going to bother seeing how many Gitmo articles they have compared to articles about the concentration camp system in North Korea. Go look at the site for yourself and it should be clear what a joke this organization is in regards to North Korean human rights. Finally don’t even get me started on Amnesty International’s plants in the military.
To make matters worse, in the CNN interview T. Kumar has the nerve to say that Amnesty International has been warning the international community not to be “complacent” on North Korean human rights. Amnesty International is the one guilty for being complacent on human rights abuses in North Korea and now they are trying to make it look like they have been warning the world all along what is going on in North Korea. What joke. If the media wants to get a real North Korean human rights expert they should give Dr. Norbert Vollertsen a call. He may be a little goofy at times but at least he is an authentic North Korean human rights expert unlike these frauds at Amnesty International. There are a variety of other experts out there as well like Dr. Andrei Lankov that are much better subject matter experts on North Korean human rights than Amnesty International.
Yet despite Amnesty International’s susposed concern for North Korean human rights, on the front page of their website they have nothing about North Korea and yet have their stupid Gitmo link. Buried in their news section they do have a press release about the 12 year sentences given to the two journalists:
North Korea sentenced two US journalists to 12 years imprisonment with hard labour on Monday. The Central Court in Pyongyang convicted Laura Ling and Euna Lee of an unspecified “grave crime” against the nation. There are no appeals in the North Korean judicial system.
“These two foreign journalists were subjected to the failures and shortcomings of the North Korean judicial system: no access to lawyers, no due process, no transparency,” said Roseann Rife, Amnesty International’s Asia-Pacific Deputy Director. “The North Korean judicial and penal systems are more instruments of suppression than of justice.” [Amnesty.org]
Incredibly Amnesty International had more press releases and even conducted a special investigation against the South Korean government for last summers mad cow protests. Does anyone think there will be any special investigation or “Wear Orange Days” organized by Amnesty International to publicize North Korean human rights violations? Don’t get your hopes up because they cannot even give a front page link on their website for quite possibly the world’s greatest human rights violators, the North Korean regime.










2:45 pm on June 11th, 2009 1
Obama mentions North Korea so it's time for AI to get into the act…neat…
You hit the nail on the head with this one — and the people in AI should honestly feel ashamed of themselves trying to speak out about NK now.
That doesn't mean I wish they'd be quiet. If they'd finally start covering NK like the should have been all along – it would be good.
But they can't escape being damned for what they haven't done and what they say they stand for.
4:14 pm on June 11th, 2009 2
I call for a boycott of all Korean goods until the Kaesong Slave Labor camp is shuttered. I bet the crap they sell doesn't say "Made in DPRK"… just like those Jewish slave made goods didn't say "Made in Aushwitz". And since you can't tell… boycott all Korean made products.
Any response from K-Swiss about their use of slave labor to make shirts?
George Bush had the ability to talk us into one war…and we went into Iraq!? Should have been regime change in North Korea!!
4:42 pm on June 11th, 2009 3
WTF?? CNN ran another story you had talked about a month ago.
http://edition.cnn.com/2009/CRIME/06/11/veteran.i…
5:16 pm on June 11th, 2009 4
AI is noticeably absent from my reading list on NK human rights. They seem to be more of an opportunistic organization driven by others' reports of human rights violations than an investigative one.
Their script seems to be to wait for a journalist or protester to be arrested, and then to try to amplify public reaction in response. Obviously this scheme is subject to manipulation, and there's a huge selection bias towards areas where news is easy to collect.
I suppose there's a certain threshold within which this model can be effective, namely Western-style democracies with free press, and in less democratic countries where Western influence is still strong. In these areas people can be shocked by small aberrations in civil rights, and the drama plays out well.
But, as Stalin said, a million deaths is a statistic, and AI's pop politics aren't much of a response to that.
11:40 pm on June 11th, 2009 5
Thanks for the link. That explains why I have been getting so much search engine traffic lately on that posting then.
1:31 pm on June 27th, 2009 6
I wouldn't go as far to say that T. Kumar is a fraud…
but I agree that AI, an organization whose sole mission is to investigate, report on, and mobilize letter writing campaigns, has been extremely lazy over the past couple of years with regard to North Korean human rights and refugee issues.
Also, I really do not understand the disparity between AI-South Korea and its coverage of North Korea. Ridiculous. That is like documenting South Africa while ignoring Darfur.
That Roseann Rife quote you posted only shows how ignorant she is. Examine the understatement — she doesn't know what she's talking about.
Human Rights Watch isn't much better…thanks for inspiring me to post on this. Coming soon.
6:51 pm on June 27th, 2009 7
Excellent entry!
You're right, these organizations that claim to be for human rights in fact have their own agenda other than human rights. They are not very active in places where it is actually dangerous to operate and seem to have a problem with investigating regimes that are leftist.
I was never stupid enough to fall for Amnesty International and one of the things I am proud of is that I never signed up for that crap even when I was in high school.
1:10 am on June 30th, 2009 8
[...] king of pop deserves his homage), the dedicated few stragglers left to work behind the scenes, and the feigned concern of those who jump on the [...]
10:25 am on October 22nd, 2009 9
I was wondering what was going on with Amnesty International. This clears up things somewhat but in a sad way. Thanks for writing this.