It is about time but the two Indian sailors jailed for no reason in Korea have been finally been released:
Seafarers Captain Jasprit Chawla and his chief officer Syam Chetan returned to Mumbai on Saturday after being detained in South Korea for 18 months.
In December 2007, a crane barge rammed their stationary ship in stormy weather. The accident caused a spillage of 10,000 tonnes of oil out of the 2,60,000 tonnes that the ship was carrying. The seafarers were jailed on charges of negligence and causing environmental damage. The ship was Hong Kong-registered.
Since their arrest, the National Union of Seafarers of India (NUSI) had campaigned for their release. On their arrival, Abdulgani Serang, general secretary of the NUSI, said: “We were inspired by the support of the Indian people. Now that the two are back, we are going to ask for greater action against the government and other associations that had worked overtime to ensure the illegal detention of the two seafarers.”
While Captain Chawla flashed victory signs to the media, Mr. Chetan’s young son burst into tears, overwhelmed by the huge media presence. However, he later danced to the drumbeats of the victory rally held outside the Mumbai’s international airport.
“The 18 months were the worst part of my life,” said Captain Chawla. “During the interrogation, I thought I would never be able to get back home. The interrogation was conducted in Korean, which we could not follow. Even the judge kept shouting at me; he was not fair. We also received little support from the Indian Consulate in South Korea.” Asked about their future plans, both men said they were relieved to be back in India and intended to spend time with family. “I would eventually like to go back to sea,” said Mr. Chetan.
“Probe biased” In 2007, after initial interrogation, the two men were found innocent by a Korean lower court. However, they were convicted by a High Court in December 2008. This was done after Samsung Heavy Industries, which owned the crane barge that rammed their ship, demanded a second investigation.
According to Rajesh Tandon, a colleague, “This second investigation was biased because it was backed by Samsung, whose turnover accounts for 33 per cent of Korea’s GDP [Gross Domestic Product].” [The Hindu]
As I wrote before on this issue I figured these two would be released on suspended sentences. It is important to remember that in Korea if you are driving a car and sitting at a stop light and someone rear ends you, you are partly to blame for the accident for simply being stopped at a stop light because the way the Korean legal system looks at it, if you weren’t on the road the accident would not have happened. This same logic applies to this oil spill. Also keep in mind Samsung has a huge influence in the Korean government and would be eager to share blame on the accident to reduce their own liability. This is the same process that plays out for US servicemembers that are jailed on dubious charges. By freeing them with a suspended sentence on appeal, this saves face for the Korean legal system, continues to reduce Samsung’s liability for the accident, while at the same time letting the two crew members convicted to go free. It is messed up, but it is the way things are done in Korea.







9:24 am on June 15th, 2009 1
Not only is this messed up to do this to these two men it is Selfish, Greedy, Despicable, and Inhumane.
10:28 am on June 15th, 2009 2
"Huge influence" as in confirmed bribery of, right?
12:02 am on June 16th, 2009 3
It's just too bad that all shipping companies didn't boycott Korea by just refusing to sail it's waters for what it did to those two sailors. You want oil? nah, I don't think so. You have a shipment of LG Tv's for the states? Nah, I don't think it's safe to sail your waters at this time.
1:08 pm on June 16th, 2009 4
This incident really riles me. I wish India had boycotted all Korean products over this issue as Korea (or should I say the Republic of Samseong) may then have been forced to notice the ridicularity of their nationalistic justice system at times.
From what I gather, most Koreans are unaware of this issue.