ROK Drop

Avatar of GI KoreaBy on June 23rd, 2010 at 8:25 am

Is Colonel Dean Hess A Korean War Fraud or Hero?

» by in: Korean War

Here is an e-mail I received recently from an 80 year old Korean War veteran that wanted to share with readers a fraud that is he believes is being perpetuated by another Korean War veteran:

Dear Sir:

I am terribly disappointed to note that the US Air Force will once again perpetuate the myth that Col. Dean Hess had ANY THING to do with the actual rescue of 950 children and a hundred orphanage staff n the Kiddy Car Airlift of 20 December, 1950.  It is obvious that Col. Hess must have participated in the design of your new display dealing with the Kiddy Car Airlift that is to be opened later this month.  (I have received copies of the display panels.) Once again, by innuendo, he wants credit for something he did not do, did not organize, did not supervise, had no knowledge of what was actually happening, did not witness and even tried to delay.  And once again you cite in your display the book Battle Hymn and the movie of the same name, both of which are shamelessly fraudulent statements of what actually happened.  Why this need on your part to perpetuate a fraud?  Why are you protecting Col. Hess?

Since the book was published and the movie distributed Hess has been acclaimed as the hero of the Kiddy Car Airlift.  Hess knew what had actually happened as he was briefed on the rescue by none other than Michael Strang when they had dinner in Los Angeles while the film was being shot.  Nonetheless, in his many speeches and award ceremonies where he was hailed as the Hero of the Kiddy Car Airlift he never had the moral courage to state “The persons on-the-ground who pulled off this rescue are Chaplain Blaisdell and his Chaplian’s Assistant Michael Strang.”  Hess accepts all these accolades, medals and international recognition as though he and he alone was responsible for the rescue!  Has he no shame?

On doing research on this topic I got to know Colonel Blaisdell very well and had access to all his files, photos and memoirs in addition to his verbal accounts of what actually happened.  I had access to the papers of S/Sgt Merle Y. Strang,  Blaisdell’s assistant.  In addition I did research at the US National Archives in College Park, Maryland and in the archives of the Stars and Stripes office in Tokyo, Japan where they had material going back to the Korean War.  The documentation I gathered is the basis for the essay pasted below.

While Hess was collecting medals and citations for what he did not do Chaplain Blaisdell and S/Sgt, Strang NEVER once got any recognition for their incredible rescue until  50 years after the war when Blaisdell got recognition but even then Sgt. Strang got none.  I did a search for Strang and found that he had died in 1998.  I interviewed a number of his friends and only one of then told of Mike commenting on one occasion that he had a role in the rescue of orphans in the Korean War.

Based on the information that I had gathered I submitted a request to the Chief of Chaplain’s Office of the U.S. Air Force for Strang to be awarded a posthumous Bronze Star for his role in that rescue.  It took me four years to achieve that goal.  Strang was also awarded the “Four Chaplain’s Award” of the US Air Force Chaplain’s office,  all of this due to my outrage at Hess stealing credit for what Blaisdell and Strang did with no interest or desire shown on his part to recognize the absolutely essential role of Blaisdell and Strang in the rescue of the children for which he was claiming credit.  If Hess had sought to have Blaisdell and Strang recognized for their role in the airlift his own story would be at risk so he shamelessly kept his mouth shut.

Does that behavior exemplify what you want to honor with your panels on the Kiddy Car Airlift?  If you want to give credit to Hess give him credit for raising money for the Orphans Home of Korea but even there his contribution was only a small part of the aid that home was getting.

Personally I feel that the panels you have prepared for the Kiddy Car Airlift are a continuation of Hess’ innuendo, first published in his book, that he is the hero of the Kiddy Car Airlift or, possibly now he is willing to accept a position as co-hero.  NOT SO.

How do you rectify this error?   1. Remove all reference to the book Battle Hymn and the movie, both of which are fraudulent statements of the rescue.  2.  Give Hess credit for helping establish the shelter to receive the children and his on-going support for that orphanage.  3.  Clearly indicate that it was Blaisdell and Strang who deserve full credit for the rescue of the children in the Kiddy Car Airlift.  Do not, by innuendo, attempt to sustain Hess’ claim to that rescue.

To sustain your own credibility as a museum of Air Force history I recommend that you replace those panels as prepared.

Regards,

George F. Drake, Ph.D., Coordinator
Korean War Children’s Memorial Project
gdrake@nas.com
www.koreanchildren.org
www.georgefdrake.org

ROK Drop readers may remember the profile I did on Chaplain Blaisdell as one of my Heroes of the Korean War.  My profile on Blaisdell included a section on the controversy with Colonel Hess.  Below the fold Mr. Drake offers more details about the alleged fraud being perpetuated by Hess. It seems to me to be pretty clear that Hess is taking credit for things he did not do because of the false depiction of Kiddy Car Airlift in the movie Battle Hymn.  So what does everyone else think about this issue.  Please vote in the poll below:

Note that the text below the fold is further information provided by Mr. Drake to support his criticism of COL Hess:

When the Chinese forces were approaching the northern edge of Seoul in December of 1950 Air Force Chaplain Russell L. Blaisdell and his Chaplain’s Assistant S/Sgt Merle Y. Strang, arranged for trucks to take 950 children and 80 orphanage staff of the Seoul Receiving Center and another smaller orphanage out of Seoul to Inchon to board an LST for escape to Pusan at the southern tip of the Korean peninsula. Chaplain Blaisdell was responsible for the rescue of many of these children from the streets of the devastated city in the months prior to their evacuation for Inchon. It was Blaisdell and Strang who stayed by the orphans and staff in a 35 ft. by 70 ft school building for four and a half days waiting for the ship that never arrived.

It was Chaplain Blaisdell who, on a desperate trip back to Seoul, with Sgt. Strang as driver of his jeep, made arrangements for the flight of sixteen C-54s to fly the children and staff from Kimpo airport the next morning to Cheju-do Island located to the south of the Korean Peninsula. It was Blaisdell and Strang who commandeered the trucks (Blaisdell “pulled rank” to take the trucks away from another unit loading cement on a boat in Inchon harbor) necessary to transport the children, staff and 15 tons of food and belongings to Kimpo Airport on the morning of the 20th of December. Hess had nothing to do with any of this and was totally unaware of the exigencies faced by Blaisdell at every step of the way in effecting this rescue.

On the 19th of December as soon as Blaisdell had arranged with Colonel T.C. Rogers, Assistant Director of Operations for the Fifth Air Force, for the flight of C-54s to arrive at Kimpo the next morning he wired Hess that he would arrive on Cheju-do Island on the 20th with the children. Hess wired back that the situation on Cheju-do was not ready for them and asked Blaisdell to delay the operation. Blaisdell responded that there was no way he would postpone the rescue flights. Other than this exchange of messages initiated by Colonel Blaisdell there was no other contact between Hess and Blaisdell regarding the rescue of the children between their last meeting in Taegu a week earlier and their meeting on Cheju-do after the rescue.

Hess states in his book Battle Hymn that he desperately was trying to make arrangements for the flight of C-54s from the Combat Cargo Command. No one doubts that he was working on that task but nowhere does he clearly state that he actually made contact with anyone who made a commitment to send the planes to rescue the children. If, in fact, he did make that contact and obtained a commitment for the flight of C-54s Hess gives no indication of how he got that information to Chaplain Blaisdell so Blaisdell could get the children to the airport to meet the rescue aircraft on time. Hess is portrayed in the book Battle Hymn, the movie and in later newspaper articles as desperately calling every one he could to get a flight of planes to rescue the children. We can agree that Colonel Hess was concerned about the children but the facts show that it was Blaisdell and not Hess who was successful in making contact with the Combat Cargo Command to bring in the flight of C-54s to rescue the children.

In other words Colonel Hess actually had nothing to do with the successful rescue of the children in the famous Kiddy Car Airlift. Accordingly it is incomprehensible how Hess could successfully claim over the years to be the one who rescued the children.

Once the children were located at Cheju-do Colonel Hess was in regular contact with the orphanage and provided extensive assistance. Besides the involvement of Hess and his crew many tons of material aid and tens of thousands of dollars were coming from persons in the U.S. and from military units in Korea and Japan to help the orphans. Most of this was as a result of Hal Boyle’s Associated Press article on the rescue that appeared in newspapers throughout the United States. Colonel Blaisdell went to Cheju-do with an air shipment of aid packages on several occasions but Colonel Hess was there on a regular basis doing all he could for the welfare of the children.

Hess’s first inference that he was the one responsible for the rescue of the children in the Kiddy Car Airlift appeared in his autobiography Battle Hymn which was first published in 1956 almost six years after the actual air lift. On the book jacket one reads “But Colonel Hess will perhaps be best remembered for his heroic efforts in Seoul, Korea, in 1951 [sic.] on behalf of thousands of defenseless Korean orphans about to be engulfed by the Chinese Communist armies sweeping down from the north. Tormented by the sight of these homeless doomed children in the streets of Seoul, he shepherded them to the Seoul airport where he sent out a distress call to his commander. At the last minute, a Fifth Air Force airlift, later to become famous as “Operation Kiddy Car” picked up the orphans and flew them to safety on Cheju Island off the southern coast of Korea.” This statement is total fiction and part of a publisher’s campaign to sell the book as a true story.

This blatant misrepresentation of the facts of the case was but the beginning of a steady flow of falsehoods. The book Battle Hymn as a grossly self serving distortion of the facts of the Kiddy Car Airlift and a poorly researched document. Had Hess actually read any of the media coverage given the Kiddy Car Airlift, which he refers to in the book, he would have been able to write a much better and more accurate account of what actually happened with regard to the airlift. The lack of accurate information in the book regarding the airlift is inexcusable since Hess, after leaving Korea, was appointed Director of Air Force Information Services and had access to everything published in the Pacific Stars & Stripes newspaper on the rescue.

The errors of the book were magnified in the movie. In the movie, which was presented as a true story, Hess is shown walking with the children from Inchon to Kimpo Airport. None of them walked. The movie doesn’t even mention Blaisdell and leaves the viewer believing that it was Hess who organized the rescue and was with the children during their time of trial.

In the first several years after the rescue the media recognized Colonel Blaisdell as the person who successfully rescued the children and orphanage staff in the Kiddy Car Airlift but after the release of the book and movie in 1956 and 1957 no one went back to the earlier records to ascertain the truth. The accepted story from then on was that it was Colonel Hess who rescued the children. And, it seemed that Hess began to believe the distortions as truth and accepted credit for a rescue he did not organize, did not manage, tried to delay and was not even witness to.

This is unconscionable as Hess had dinner one night in Los Angeles during the filming of the movie Battle Hymn with Mike Strang who had assisted Chaplain Blaisdell in the rescue. Hess asked Strang about the rescue but once knowing the truth from one of the actual heroes of that airlift he refused to help Strang get a role in the movie. Even if Hess had never read any of the articles printed in the Pacific Stars & Stripes, Colliers Magazine, Time Magazine and other publications about the rescue back in 1950, 1951, 1952 or 1953 he now had information on what really happened directly from Sgt. Strang.

It seems that Colonel Hess was now a captive of his own inaccurate portrayal of the rescue as presented in his book. The media now had him as the hero, the person who walked with the children from Seoul to Inchon and back to Kimpo for the rescue. Now that the rights to the book were in the hands of movie producers Hess had lost control of the story. And the story really got out of control when the movie was promoted throughout Korea and the U.S. as a true portrayal of the Kiddy Car Airlift.

The articles published in newspaper accounts about the book and film were outrageous in the amount of incorrect information that was printed. From various issues of the Pacific Stars and Stripes we quote, “Using AF C-119 aircraft, Hess gathered some 800 orphans from different sections of the country and flew them to safety”. (27 Sept. 1956) “Hess organized “Operation Kiddy Car” (12 Jan. 1957). “Battle Hymn Has Seoul Premiere…Korean waifs and ROK Air force bands teamed up to provide fanfare marking the premiere of “Battle Hymn” describing Col. Dean Hess’s heroic actions in saving trapped Korean orphans from the Chinese communists in the winter of 1950-1951.” (30 June 1957). “Air Force Col. Dean Hess, famed for his life-saving rescue flights of Korean orphans during the 1950 fighting…” (21 July 1959).

On 18 December 1960 we read “Hess to get ROK (Republic of Korea) Honor. U.S. Air Force Col. Dean Hess, whose Korean War exploits were depicted in the movie “Battle Hymn,” will receive the Republic of Korea Order of Cultural Merit Tuesday in Seoul ceremonies. ROK President Posun Yun is scheduled to present the award at a banquet in Hess’ honor. During the Korean War Hess was instrumental in saving the lives of some 800 orphans. He airlifted the waifs from battle-torn areas to Cheju Island, some 70 miles off the southeast coast of Korea.”

And on 21 December we read, “Republic of Korea President Posun Yun Tuesday presented the Order of Cultural Merit to U.S. Air Force Col. Dean E. Hess, the “flying parson” of Korean War fame. Hess, first American military man ever presented the Korean medal, received it for his humanitarian assistance to Korean children. … The presentation was made 10 years to the day after his Operation Kiddy Car airlifted 1,000 Korean orphans from the communist-menaced Seoul to the safety of Cheju-do. … His famous airlift was carried out virtually under the nose of the communist armies streaming toward the Korean capital. He managed to round up 16 planes to fly the children south away from the battle.”

Newspapers on 18 January 1962 reported “Col. Hess To Receive Sopa Award. SEOUL, The annual Sopa Memorial Award will be presented to U.S. Air Force Col. Dean E. Hess during ceremonies here at 2:30 p.m. Saturday at the Korea House. Hess, public information officer of the Fifth Air Force, is being cited for his extraordinary service in saving some 900 homeless war children during the Korean War.”

The above are cited as examples of the recognition Col. Hess received for an airlift he did not organize, a rescue he did not manage and even tried to delay, and, from all evidence in his own report of the incident, he wasn’t even an eye witness to! It is obvious that the reporters following Hess’s every move in Korea used his book and the movie as their source of information on his role in the airlift. Nowhere does Hess explain that he had no contact with Colonel Blaisdell after their meeting a week prior to the evacuation of the children from Seoul, knew nothing of their wait in Inchon or return to Kimpo Airport, that he had no contact with Chaplain Blaisdell regarding their rescue other than to attempt to delay the rescue one day until he could complete arrangements in Cheju-do to receive the children. Never does Hess give credit to Blaisdell and Strang for their role in the operation.

But then Hess also fails to give credit to any one else who was helping the children once they were located on Cheju-do. To read his book one would think it was his unit that was providing the bulk of the material and financial support for the orphanage. In reality the material aid coming to the Orphans’ Home of Korea as a result of Hal Boyle’s article far exceeded anything Hess and his unit raised from family and contacts in the states. Nowhere does Hess mention the tens of thousands of dollars coming to the Orphans’ Home of Korea from military units other than his own. Hess does not like to share credit with anyone. This additional distortion of the facts led to the false conclusion that Hess was the hero not only of the Kiddy Car Airlift but also in helping the children survive their first years on Cheju-do.

Once the movie was released it seemed impossible for Hess to say “This is not a true portrayal of what happened.” Hess had become a captive of his own earlier mis-statement of the facts of the rescue. Recently Hess has privately, but not publicly, stated that he was upset with the way the movie distorted the story of the rescue but the truth of the matter is that his concern for that distortion of the facts did not prevent him from accepting the honors due someone else. Nowhere does Hess state “Wait a minute. This has gone too far. I want to acknowledge the role of Chaplain Blaisdell and S/Sgt Strang in the rescue of these children.” All of this is very sad in that Colonel Hess was truly concerned with the plight of the orphans and he did provide extensive aid to Whang On Soon and the Orphans Home of Korea. He did not need to steal credit for the airlift to be honored for his work on behalf of the war orphans of Korea. Hess’ role as a fighter pilot and as “Father of the Korean Air Force” truly justifies his status as a Korean War Hero. His work on behalf of the children in the Orphans Home of Korea and with other Korean War orphans justifies him being honored for his work with children but only as one of hundreds, if not thousands, of other servicemen doing the same in othe rparts of Korea. But by also taking credit for what did not belong to him, i.e., credit for the Kiddy Car Airlift, he seriously damages his own credibility.

Hess, who is also characterized as “Preacher” and the “flying Parson” is an ordained minister who gave up his pulpit for the cockpit. His theft of credit for the Kiddy Car Airlift leaves one to wonder about his sense of commitment to his religious credentials.

Drake recently asked Blaisdell how come he and Strang allowed Hess to take the credit for the airlift and accept all those honors and say nothing for all these years? “Well,” Blaisdell responded, “Mike wrote me a letter about this in 1957, right after the film “Battle Hymn” came out. He was angry.” In his letter Mike Strang bitterly complained about Hess taking credit for the rescue and wanted to ‘blow the whistle’ on him. But Blaisdell responded to Strang’s letter writing

“The goal of our efforts, in regard to the orphans … was the saving of lives, which would otherwise have been lost. That was accomplished. In a sense, Mike, well-doing has its own reward, which is not measured in dollars, prestige, or good will, provided the avowed principle is fulfilled in the publication of the book and the preparation of the movie, which is to turn all proceeds over to the orphans. I rest content and would not becloud the issue at this time with an attempt to criticize or correct the portions which we know to be false. In the event that the proceeds did not go to the orphans in Korea I may be inclined to change my attitude.”

To Strang’s credit he took Blaisdell’s advise and said nothing. We have accounts of individuals receiving a Presidential Citation for saving the lives of four Korean war orphans and yet here we have a former Air Force Sgt. and his commanding officer, willing to keep quiet about their role in the rescue of over 950 orphans just to insure that Hess could maximize the income from his book and the movie about that air lift.

So far as is known Hess did turn over to the orphanage all the proceeds from the book and the movie. For that he deserves credit. But Hess, by distorting his role in the airlift, denied both Colonel Russell L. Blaisdell and Sgt. Merle (Mike) Strang the credit due them for one of the most dramatic rescue operations of the Korean War. More than 50 years after the fact Blaisdell was finally honored in Korea for the rescue of the children in the Kiddy Car Airlift. Recently, at the dedication of the Korean War Children’s Memorial in Bellingham, Washington, Blaisdell received the “Four Chaplain’s Award” of the Office of the Chief of Chaplains of the U.S. Air Force for the rescue of the children in the Kiddy Car Airlift.

Unfortunately, Mike Strang was not at that gathering along with Chaplain Blaisdell. He died in Milwaukee, Wisconsin in 1998 without recognition of any sort during his lifetime for his role in that rescue.

Tags: , , ,
- 4,088 views
16
  • Tom
    3:37 am on June 23rd, 2010 1

    I voted, no he is not.

    Americans are such pretenders. They want to be heroes. It's no wonder they idolize war.

  • Retired GI
    6:37 am on June 23rd, 2010 2

    The older we get the greater we are. When you consider that Americans are kind a great when they are BORN—that is quite a statement. :grin:

  • Hamilton
    6:40 am on June 23rd, 2010 3

    If an American pulled Tom out of a burning car saving his life he would spit in his face. You are a vile little troll Tom, ever wonder why even the cute leftist girls hate you?

  • Retired GI
    6:53 am on June 23rd, 2010 4

    I thought he WAS a "cute leftist girl". :shock:

  • Hamilton
    10:29 am on June 23rd, 2010 5

    RG, he is only a girl in the thin sense that he likes catching not pitching. He will claim he is asexual while he frolics in the NE.

  • Gerry
    11:08 am on June 23rd, 2010 6

    I've been reading up on 'Pork Chop Hill' lately and have come across a number of people who claim to have been in the battle, battles. Often the dates, companies, discriptions, are way out of line.

    Often they were part of neighboring battles around the same time. Yet, no one is remembered for outpost Dale, Arsenal hill or Erie, but they happened at the same time, so they associate themselves with 'pork chop hill'.

    I suspect Col Hess may have done the same. Not that he doesn't deserve recognition, only that he took it in lieu of others who deserved it more.

  • Marcus Ambrose
    11:30 am on June 23rd, 2010 7

    Right, Tom. Americans are the only ones that want to be heroes. No one else. No Korean wants to be the hero soccer star? No Korean wants to be the hero to rescue someone? B.S. You are caught in your own lies Tom. Everyone in the WORLD grows up wanting to do great things.

  • Songtan1
    9:22 pm on June 23rd, 2010 8

    Tom. Go away, far away… :twisted:

  • bdiego
    9:45 am on June 24th, 2010 9

    The problem with history is books copy other books copying other books until one source becomes every source. Happens all the time. Didn't we even go to war in Iraq over something just like that? Yeah..if even the CIA gets duped you can imagine a small little shop like a mere Air museum will.

  • Sgt. William Soileau
    9:55 am on November 20th, 2010 10

    Well as far as Heros go, mine are Jesus, St Micheal, Fr. Francis P. Duffy and my daughter. GOD BLESS AMERICA !!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Jeffrey Miller
    3:38 pm on November 20th, 2010 11

    You might be interested in reading this story that I wrote in 2001 covering Mr. Blaisdell's visit to Korea and meeting the orphans for the first time since he rescued them in 1950-51.

    http://jeffreyalanmiller.wordpress.com/2008/04/26

  • Kevin
    6:23 am on November 29th, 2010 12

    I find it curious that so much is being made of Colonel Hess telling his story. His story, told from his point of view, about his experiences in Korea. Colonel Hess’s autobiography, Battle Hymn, is just that; he isn’t solely telling the story of Operation Kiddie Car, but of his entire experience there, of which Kiddie Car was just a part.

    He did not seek to steal credit from Chaplain Blaisdell or Staff Sergeant Strang. In fact, in chapter 19 of "Battle Hymn," Hess relates how he and Blaisdell were both working to arrange transport for the orphans.

    The only reason Colonel Hess even wrote the book in the first place was to raise money to build a new orphanage in Seoul. He sent his proceeds from the book and the movie rights back to Korea, some five years after he left. Such was Colonel Hess’s commitment to those orphans, he even adopted one himself.

    Not to take anything away from the accomplishments of Blaisdell and Strang, but there is proof that the orphanage’s administrator and the orphans recognized Colonel Hess as having done much for the orphanage and orphans: in October 1956, Colonel Hess was featured on the Ralph Edwards television show, "This is Your Life". For that program honoring Colonel Hess, the orphanage director, Mrs. Whang, and several of the orphans made the trip to Los Angeles to pay their respects to him.

    As far as the movie goes, Hess had sold the rights of his story to the film company. When you do that, they can change it if they want to. Even though Hess was the USAF liaison on the film, his primary job (even though they were filming his own life story) was to protect the Air Force’s interests, not his own. Even then, the filmmakers wouldn’t have to make any changes he suggested, they still had the rights to the story.

    Certainly Blaisdell and Strang did much to help the orphans in Korea, both at the orphanage and during the airlift, and of course they deserve credit for their work. But to say that Hess stole credit is getting it wrong. The stories don’t contradict one another, they are merely told by different people from different points of view.

    I am unsure of George Drake’s reasons for wanting to malign Colonel Hess, but I ask that you look at all sides of the story, remember that the movie is only “based on the true story,” not the true story, and be objective and thoughtful before you suggest a man is a fraud.

    P.S.: Some other thoughts, since Dr. Drake mentions Hess receiving and accepting awards:

    Not all, if any, of his military decorations were awarded for his role in the airlift. Please see aviation historian James Farmer's article in the June 2009 issue of "Flight Journal" magazine, in which he writes of Hess's role in what is termed "The Strike that Saved Korea."

    Please also see Farmer's article in the February 2009 issue of "Air" magazine, which discusses Hess's time in Korea, as well as the production of the film "Battle Hymn". Starting on page 46, Farmer deals with the Blaisdell controversy.

  • Patricia Walworth Wo
    3:41 pm on December 16th, 2010 13

    WOW. G.I. Korea, what stuck in your craw? To whom are you related to make you so angry. Were you not glorified the way you believed you should have been? Did no one publish your book and make a movie of your life and that is the Colonel's fault? Did he just happen to become a Colonel without earning it?

    I'm almost finished with the book and felt like he talked of all the works others did, that it wasn't just him. I saw the movie 2/14/1957 when it was premiered in Marietta, Ohio. I can't believe the Government, the Air Force, let a fraud be perpetuated. Are people after you G.I.? Are they hiding around the corners to jump out at you? That seems to be whom you are.

  • dmk
    8:26 pm on May 14th, 2011 14

    I second what #12 – Kevin, 11-29-2010 wrote, and want to continue a bit.

    I just finished reading “Battle Hymn,” and pages 184-5-6-7 speak of Operation Kiddy Car. No where in these pages does Col. Hess take credit for the C-54s showing up. He said they just “appeared” because on page 185 he’s trying to get an LST and on page 186 you know they would never materialize. Then he was wondering about doing the transporting in many, many trips using C-47s.

    He said it was Russ (Lt. Col. Russell Blaisdell) who was to see about getting trucks and who did. Hess never said he was in Seoul with the orphans . . . it was Russ for a time and then others (not mentioned) who were with the kids and the trucks, getting to Kimpo airport. Hess never said he walked with the orphans those 10 miles. The reader knows it was other people because Hess was, all the time, at Kimpo airport trying to get air transport for when the kids would get there.

    Hess said that it was General Partridge who sent the C-54s for the evacuation, and though Hess said on p. 186 that “he laid siege to Fifth Air Force headquarters,” he also said on p. 187 that “Chaplain Blaisdell was camping at Fifth Air Force headquarters, adding his powerful persuasion.” And then “The answer to our prayers came like a miracle.” AND after the last child was loaded onto the C-54s and C-47s, Hess “climbed back into my F-51 and with a light heart flew south for the day’s work.”

    I look at it this way . . . someone always needs to take charge in order to get things done (and that happens with m-a-n-y helpers at times, as was with this case). And yes, many times in life it’s the “leader” who gets the acclamations, although it was “the crew” who carried the load of the work. What was bestowed on Col. Hess were decisions made by others. He didn’t give himself awards. Yes, possibly he was a little amiss on not extending as much inclusion to the others as he could have, but I’m not judging. I don’t have first-hand knowledge.

    Praise be to Blaisdell and Strang for what part they played in these children’s lives. Aren’t we overwhelmingly in gratitude that someone who did have the ability and authority to pull some strings (Hess, Partridge, Blaisdell with getting the trucks, others), went possibly “outside” the rule book of war, and did what they did to save these children’s lives?

    If Lt. Col. – Chaplain Blaisdell and Staff Sergeant Strang also wrote autobiographies and felt they needed to set the record straight regarding the role they played in this one item of many “calls to duty” in the Korean War, then I’d like to read their stories, too. But if they didn’t sit down and put in the time and due-diligence to write, then silence is acquiesence.

    But that’s for only here on Earth. Believe me, God knows where our hearts lie and if they didn’t write autobiographies, they knew it wasn’t man they were giving their life and deeds to! As “they” say, “There’s no limit as to how far a man can go or how much he can do if it doesn’t matter who gets the credit.”

    Blessings to all, and especially my relative, Rueben, who didn’t come back alive from that war, who didn’t have a chance to tell about it. I’m thankful Col. Hess did, and that he did write the book, and that the proceeds (as has been mentioned, because I don’t have first-hand knowledge of knowing) were used for the children. Again, when God measures a man, he puts the tape measure around the heart and not the head.

    Here we are, 60 years later, and we still have our American men (my husband for 26 years, and now our 2 oldest as career military, many nephews, son-in-law) still on or having been on the front lines having, at times, to face the “evil” that Col. Hess spoke of. I wish the book could be read by every young man and woman today who has to kill someone. Let’s just pray that they have a commander such as Col. Hess and can learn to live with it in order for their own psyche to also not be destroyed with the one they killed.

  • Lyle Pope
    5:55 pm on April 2nd, 2012 15

    I served in the Navy at Pusan, Korea, in the spring and summer of 1954. When I first saw the movie Battle Hymn, I was really impressed with what Col Dean Hess supposedly did for those Korea children. During my Korean service, I saw many homeless kids..no parents and no place to stay. I was shocked to discover that Hess took credit for something he didn’t do. What a shame.

  • Kevin
    5:40 pm on April 3rd, 2012 16

    Lyle,

    First, I’d like to thank you for your service. I, too, served in the Navy, though many years after you. Thanks for paving the way for us.

    I do wonder, though, if you read any of the other comments (especially my previous one, number 12, and DMK’s, which immediately precedes yours). Please consider that there are two sides to every story, and while the film “Battle Hymn” makes much of the airlift, it is actually quite a small part in Col. Hess’s book. DMK’s comment especially makes note of Hess’s version of events and how he doesn’t take credit. Another point to consider is that many, if not all, of Col. Hess’s awards and decorations from the Korean government were due to his service training their air force, and not for his participation in the airlift.

    Thanks!

 

RSS feed for comments on this post | TrackBack URI

By submitting a comment here you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution.

Bad Behavior has blocked 32056 access attempts in the last 7 days.