ROK Drop

By on July 12th, 2010 at 5:50 am

The Truth & Reconciliation Commission Recommends US Compensation for 8 Korean War Incidents

» by in: Korean War

It looks like the highly politicized Korean Truth & Reconciliation Commission may finally be completing its work with this announcement:

A commission charged with investigating wartime atrocities has found that American troops killed groups of South Korean civilians on 138 separate occasions during the Korean War.

But in a flurry of rulings made in the past few days, the commission decided not to seek compensation or criminal charges in about 130 of the cases either for lack of evidence or because it found that the killings were militarily justified.

The findings, which have not been formally announced and will end the commission’s work, appear to reflect the desire of the conservative government of President Lee Myung-bak to wrap up the inquiry and to avoid antagonizing the United States.

The commission will recommend that South Korea start negotiations with Washington to seek compensation for the victims in the remaining eight cases, the president of the commission said Friday.

In the other 130 cases, the commission could not find evidence of illegality by the American military or it determined that the deaths resulted from “military necessity,” said Lee Young-jo, president of the government’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission.

“They were more like cases of negligence than of liability or war crimes,” said Mr. Lee, whose commission wrapped up its four-year-old investigation on June 30. “For such a low level of unlawfulness, I don’t think any government negotiations with the United States for compensation are necessary.”  [New York Times]

Read the rest at the link, but the article did not have a complete listing of what the 8 incidents were.  If anyone has a link to all 8 incidents please let me know.  Anyway since the article was written by Choe Sang-hun of No Gun Ri fame he of course brought up the No Gun Ri incident.  He however makes no mention in the article if No Gun Ri was one of the 8 incidents the T&R Commission is recommending compensation for.  Since Choe makes no mention of this it leads me to believe it is not one of the 8 incidents cited in the report, which is yet another blow to the creditability of the Associated Press team’s article on the incident.

One of the incidents the article did cite from the T&R Commission’s report was the shelling by the USS DeHaven on a group of refugees huddled on a beach.  This incident in a prior posting I was able to provide context and poke holes into the claims of what happened.  In my opinion this incident hardly qualifies as a war crime.  The other two incidents mentioned in the article I would have to do further research on to draw firm conclusions on, but judging by the faulty historical revisionism of the T&R Commission that I have uncovered in the past I remain skeptical.

Anyway I am wondering when the list of Korean War incidents where the Truth & Reconciliation Commission is recommending compensation for victims of atrocities by the North Korean and Chinese militiaries will be published?

Tags: , , , ,
- 368 views
6
  • Tweets that mention The Truth & Reconciliation Commission Recommends US Compensation for 8 Korean War Incidents | ROK Drop -- Topsy.com
    6:05 am on July 12th, 2010 1

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by denisearcoverde, GIKorea. GIKorea said: New blog post: The Truth & Reconciliation Commission Recommends US Compensation for 8 Korean War Incidents http://bit.ly/djkLmi [...]

  • odszkodowanie
    11:10 pm on August 1st, 2010 2

    interesting publication

  • Retired GI
    12:48 am on August 2nd, 2010 3

    I agree! Let the USA compensate Korea by pulling out the Troops and cutting off funding to this piece of chit country. Then they can join with their northern brothers and sisters in kissing China's asss.

    Wonder what China would say to a request for compensation?

    USA can not afford "friends" like Korea.

  • ChickenHead
    1:26 am on August 2nd, 2010 4

    I guess America should hire whoever the Japanese have been using as their comfort woman negotiator.

  • Rich V
    10:53 pm on March 2nd, 2011 5

    Just start another round of base closures, relocate a brigade of 2nd ID to Guam and watch how fast they shut up! My father has a photo book full of atrocious Korean war photos inflicted on the local civilian population, all done by the South Koreans themselves. Many of my wife's older uncles and male cousins all disappeared shortly after the inchon invasion, all allegedly murdered by the Rhee government. Just because on occasion during the summer-fall of 1950, some exhausted and scared 19 year old kid in the 1st Cav/24thID/25thID/Marine Bde pulled the trigger on an unknown shadow which turned out to have been a civilian doesn't equal an American version of Einsatzgruppe C set loose in the Ukraine in 1941-43. Doesn't the fact that US forces were operating under the UN mean that any findings should be taken up with and compensation paid by the UN?

  • 2 ID Doc
    6:20 am on April 21st, 2012 6

    How convenient that only the US military committed atrocities. No other nation (other than NK & China) committed war crimes? Because every other nation would tell South Korea to bugger off! On a similar note how many times did Dictator, um President Rhee get impeached? I have lost count. I know they impeached him at least once during the Japanese occupation when the government in exile was created, and twice during his dictatorship, er presidency during and after the Korean War. I’m sure the Rhee military was filled with saints who followed the Geneva Convention to the letter, and never conscripted soldiers by grabbing them off the streets or fields or dragging them out of their homes.

 

RSS feed for comments on this post | TrackBack URI

By submitting a comment here you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution.

Bad Behavior has blocked 15482 access attempts in the last 7 days.