ROK Drop

Avatar of GI KoreaBy on February 1st, 2013 at 6:31 pm

Is the 2nd Infantry Division Needed for Deterrence In Korea?

» by in: USFK

Below is an article from Voice of America that describes how the US military’s 2nd Infantry Division in Korea conducts tank gunnery training:

 At a time of rising tensions on the Korean peninsula, a quartet of U.S. Army “Abrams” M1-A2SEP tanks rolls onto the frozen ground of the Rodriguez Live Fire Range near the DMZ during one of the coldest days of the winter.

The tanks and their crews, from Dragon Company of the 1st Battalion’s 72nd Armor Regiment (1-72 AR), are a small but lethal component of the U.S. Army’s 2nd Infantry Division stationed close to the tense border separating North and South Korea.

The division has the unenviable task of holding off – until reinforcements arrive – a much larger enemy force, should there be an invasion similar to the one that began the Korean War in 1950.

The tankers’ advanced qualification exercise (known as a gunnery table XII) not only involves the crews inside the 70-ton 1,500-horsepower vehicles, but 400 other support personnel scattered across the range, including those in an observation tower and a large heated tent that serves as the battalion tactical operations center.  [VOA News]

You can read more about tank gunnery at the link.  You can also read my profile of the Korea Training Center at the below link:

  • A Profile of the Korea Training Center

A few important things to point out is that the 2nd Infantry Division is not really a division.  It basically has one combat brigade backed up with aviation and logistical support.  The rest of the division is stationed stateside.  So they are not going to be holding off the North Koreans, it is going to be the job of the much larger ROK Army to do that during an invasion.  However, here is something else I found of interest at the very end of the article:

Senior security strategy researcher Hong Hyun-ik, at the Sejong Institute in Seoul, says despite the huge economic disparity between the two Koreas, the South likely would not be able to repel the North without such American units as the 2nd Infantry Division.

Hong contends it would be relative easy for Seoul to be captured by the North should Pyongyang again start a war. Taking this into consideration, he explains, even though South Korea “desires to have an independent defense posture it knows it must rely on U.S. forces here to have a sufficient deterrence.”

I disagree with this assessment.  I do not think it would be easy at all for the North Koreans to capture Seoul.  In fact I don’t think they would even try because of how it would slow down their invasion plans to wage urban combat in one of the world’s most densely populated cities.  The North Koreans would have to end a war very quickly because they likely do not have the logistics to sustain an attack. The only way I could imagine the North Koreans being able to capture the South is through the use of WMD against ROK forces which would end the war quicker for them before their logistics ran out.  However, as long as the US is allied with South Korea any use of these weapons would lead to an overwhelming response in kind by the US.  Thus this is the actual deterrence that keeps the situation stable on the peninsula.

The Pentagon could pull what remains of the 2nd Infantry Division from Korea tomorrow and I do not think it would have much affect on the tactical fight on the peninsula.  The 2ID is however the most visible sign of the US commitment to the US-ROK alliance by putting actual ground soldiers in harms way near the DMZ.  This is a strategic communications message to the North Koreans that the US remains committed to the security of South Korea and they best not try an invasion because it will be met with the overwhelming response they know they cannot survive.

Tags: , , , ,
- 1,716 views
13
  • Ole Tanker
    5:44 pm on February 1st, 2013 1

    After the move to Humphries, 2 ID will hold Osan and the Southetrn ports until reinforcements arrive.
    The ROK Army and US Air Force should be able to delay the NORKS long enough for that.

  • Kcbill
    11:19 pm on February 1st, 2013 2

    Add 210 Fires Brigade and the 2 MEB to your division.

  • Airdefender
    11:31 pm on February 1st, 2013 3

    #2

    I work in the Division Headquarters and have never heard of “2 MEB”. There is no MEB except as part of the TPFDD. Do you mean 2 CAB?

  • Baek In-je
    2:05 am on February 2nd, 2013 4

    I had some friends in the 2ID. Crazy mother f@#kers, every last one. But, hey…that’s what you want up front, right? It’s not like the skinny, ajumma hairdo-wearing, metrosexual, wide hipped university ROK conscripts are going to be much use in war…except as bullit catchers.

  • Kingkitty
    4:56 am on February 2nd, 2013 5

    They are needed to hold the north from invading the Bars at Tongducheon. We do not need our pawnshops, phone centers, Turkish food places, cheap knockoff shops (Thanks for that 5 dollar 49er jersey) and juicy clubs being visited by North Koreans. These places need to put up signs prohibiting them from patronizing these establishments.

  • Tom
    8:36 am on February 2nd, 2013 6

    We need the US soldiers to block all the bullets and make North Korea waste more bullets. Line them all up in a row.

  • MTB Rider
    2:06 pm on February 2nd, 2013 7

    Lame, New Tom. Totally not up to the standards of the Original Tom!

    Should we start a chant?
    Bring Back Old Tom!
    Bring Back Old Tom!

    You’re not even annoying. Just boring. Go back to class, Lame New Tom. You’re no fun. :sad:

  • Conway Eastwood
    2:48 pm on February 2nd, 2013 8

    #7

    Bring back the old Tom! :lol:

  • Kingkitty
    6:53 pm on February 2nd, 2013 9

    I miss The Old Tom When he told us Osan was North of the Han river.

    Bring back the Old Tom. New Tom is just a lame TOMmabe!

  • Leon LaPorte
    7:23 pm on February 2nd, 2013 10

    Look at it this way:

    A skinny little white guy goes into an elevator, looks up and sees this HUGE black guy standing next to him.
    The big guy sees the little guy staring at him, looks down and says”7 feet tall, 350 pounds, 20 inch member, 3 pound left testicle, 3 pound right testicle, Turner Brown.”
    The white man faints and falls to the floor.
    The big guy kneels down and brings him to, shaking him. The big guy says, “What’s wrong with you?”
    In a weak voice the little guy says, “What EXACTLY did you say to me? ”
    The big dude says, “I saw your curious look and figured I’d just give you the answers to the questions everyone always asks me.
    I’m 7 feet tall, I weigh 350 pounds, I have a 20 inch private, my left testicle weighs 3 pounds, my right testicle weighs 3 pounds, and my name is Turner Brown.”

    The small guy says, “Turner Brown!…Sweet Jesus, I thought you said, “Turn Around

  • Leon LaPorte
    7:26 pm on February 2nd, 2013 11

    1, After the move to Humphries…

    OLOLLOLOL ROTFLMAO!!!one!!11!!!eleventy!!!1!!!

    What move? It’s not happening. :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

  • jim
    5:16 pm on February 3rd, 2013 12

    11, the way they’re building down here says otherwise. maybe not this decade, but eventually.

  • Leon LaPorte
    5:53 pm on February 3rd, 2013 13

    12. That’s not who they are building for.

    Also, leadership and priorities have changed, but the construction continues. You know the military never wastes money. :lol:

 

RSS feed for comments on this post | TrackBack URI

By submitting a comment here you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution.

Bad Behavior has blocked 45516 access attempts in the last 7 days.